Comments by Helen Woodward

Comment for "Jeremy & Virginia Twice Wed--Not Your Typical Love Story"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Jeremy & Virginia Twice Wed--Not Your Typical Love Story

A portrait of a real couple, married twice and still pondering the nature of their relationship. What I liked most about this piece is that it shows how complicated and dynamic relationships are, even when they are, on the face of it, successful and enduring. We hear the couple dissect their history together, their memories overlapping in some areas, and diverging in others, the ups and downs still fresh in their memories. Ultimately the audience gets a sense that they have reached a mutual accomodation, a point where they are still married and their reasons for staying together are clearer now than ever before, which is no mean feat in these days of 50% divorce rate.
This isn't your average fairy tale love story; thankfully it is a far more realistic account of one couple's path to where they are today, still working at staying a couple. In addition, the producer uses music to great effect.

Air it on Valentines to inject a little reality into the holiday.

Comment for "Grease My Ride!"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Grease My Ride!

This is an interesting report on the use of restaurant grease for automobile fuel, which would fit easily in ME or ATC. It also features an engaging avocate for biodiesel who is planning a trip across country, powered by grease, to publicize this innovative technology.

Comment for "A Dry Wedding" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of A Dry Wedding (deleted)

An abrupt start, but a fascinating look at how big a part alcohol plays in our celebrations. In this case the wedding goes well as one would hope and expect, even without alcohol. However the lack of it, becomes a talking point, even making it into some of the speeches. In our society, alcohol is so ingrained in honoring important events that it becomes conspicuous by its absence. In this case, some guests made alternative plans, like the grooms parents who held a speakeasy in their suite, or did without, and no one was any the worse for it; others embraced the unimaginable and complied with a booze-free wedding, and felt much better for it the next day! This would make a great introduction for a talk show on the effects of alcohol; it is a lively piece that captures the celebratory atmosphere of the wedding, and the guests provide some interesting talking points.

Comment for "Welcome Baby Max"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Welcome Baby Max

This is a classic diary piece, dealing with subject matter that seems perfect for such treatment. The piece starts a few weeks before the due date, so there is no sense of what the first 2 trimesters held for the soon to be parents, nor any feel for the mounting tension and excitement that you might expect if the diary covered the whole pregnancy. The piece is short, perhaps too short, I would have liked to hear how 5 weeks bed rest due to gestational diabetes affects mom for instance; We get to hear from baby Max via fetal monitor before his birth and he gets to have the last words, or gurgles too. All round a satisfying listening experience.

Comment for "African Microbes go on Caribbean Vacation" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of African Microbes go on Caribbean Vacation (deleted)

The interview concerns the transatlantic transport of microorganisms in windblown African dust: the fact that dust can make it across the ocean AND negatively impact Caribbean coral reefs is intriguing and reminds us how much we have to learn about the environment. Unfortunately this interview doesn't do enough to pique my interest, or make me want to learn more about the subject. It is a straight interview with a fast talking microbiologist and is a little dry in content and format . If, however, you are a programmer at a radio station in the Caribbean this is essential listening as the subject matter has a direct and troubling impact on your listeners.

Comment for "Against All Odds: Hope in the Struggle-HIV/AIDS in Southern Africa"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Against All Odds: Hope in the Struggle HIV/AIDS

This unconventional collage of voices portrays the complex and tragic situation that AIDS workers and those suffering from AIDS face in Southern Africa; the pandemic endures dues to lack of financial resources and therefore access to effective drugs, and poor education. The conversational nature of the interviews in this piece makes some of the dialogue difficult to understand, and the edits are a little choppy at times. That being said there is a lot of insight and information in this piece, and it is important to hear from people that are on the front line in fighting this terrible disease.

Comment for "No-Water Urinals"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of No-Water Urinals

This is the second piece I have listened to in the Your Choice, Your Planet series produced by the Great Lakes Radio Consortium, and both have proven to be engaging and informative. In addition they provide listeners an insight into innovative and environmentally sound technologies and practices that will become essential in a future where mountains of waste are being generated and untainted water supplies are dwindling. With widespread uptake of waterless urinals huge quantities of water could be saved (some qualitative data would have enhanced the piece) and airing this piece may encourage facilities managers everywhere to think a little differently about the men's room. All that being said, when airing this piece it might be a good time to disengage the minds eye!

Comment for "High Tech Refugee Finds New Home"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of High Tech Refugee Finds New Home

The interview deals with one woman's search for her next career having spent 20 years in software marketing. Working with a career coach, she explored many different options and finally ended up in real estate, and this piece reveals the process and details the steps she took to get there. In today's world of downsizing and outsourcing, this piece is likely to be relevant to listeners everywhere.

Comment for "New Life for Old Running Shoes" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of New Life for Old Running Shoes (deleted)

This is a great piece for earth day, or any day, and a good example of a company taking responsibility for its discarded products. The company in question, Nike, has set up a scheme (Reuse a Shoe) to collect old athletic shoes that have outrun their owners' feet; they then recycle them into various rubbery products like tennis courts. By collaborating with a variety of public groups they are broadening the scheme to reach all 50 states. Nike actually has a waiting list of organizations that want to help! (Of course why wouldn't Nike set up a scheme that essentially uses free labor and plenty of good will, to collect free discarded raw materials to make products it can sell for a profit? maybe it is so it can pay better wages in it's Asian sweat shops). But seriously folks, this piece demonstrates that innovative low cost recycling schemes can help solve some of the big problems we face as a society, and it is perfect for ATC or ME.

Comment for "Dr. Ned Hallowell: Dare To Forgive"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Dr. Ned Hallowell: Dare To Forgive

I resisted listening to this piece on my computer, once I read that it was a lecture, and an hour long lecture at that. But having listened, I am glad I got over my initial reluctance. The lecture was engaging from the beginning, funny at times, and full of common sense advice and anecdotes, and the audience was clearly as engrossed as I was. It was divided evenly between ridding oneself of worry, and of anger and resentment, and therefore freeing oneself to do more constructive things instead. The good doctor lays out steps to combat these feelings in our daily life and also gives the listener an insight into how the brain manages these emotions, and how taking simple actions can affect its biochemistry, and therefore how we feel. It put me in mind of how I imagine a really good sermon should be: useful, nourishing to the spirit and good for the soul, grounded in reality, and not overly preachy.
This would be a great sunday evening show, or any evening for that matter.

Comment for "Lost at Sea: One VW Microbus"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Lost at Sea: One VW Microbus

This piece is oddly compelling in a tragic comedy kind of way; it has the feel of an urban legend, and yet the tale is told with such heart and nostalgia, that it has a fairy tale quality too. It is replete with visual details that stick in the mind, some nice use of music, and maybe a tad too much rushing water early on. The fact that the family was forced to bear witness to the tragic and drawn out demise of their VW bus for months after the intial loss, as tide after tide washed over and revealed it anew, until it was finally consumed by the sands, only adds to the pathos.

It is hard to imagine quite when this would best appear on the radio, but it should air somewhere; as a fellow reviewer suggested, the weekend ATC or ME is probably the best bet.

Comment for "Graham Shelby and the Heartbeat Story"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Graham Shelby and the Heartbeat Story

This is a sweet poignant tale, one that will be stitched into the annals of the Shelby family, and that the triplets will hear ad infinitum as they grow up, all things going well (fingers crossed that they do). The news still seems to be sinking in, as Shelby marvels at the sheer numbers involved compared to his solitary childhood; as the spectre of another miscarriage looms, he ponders whether 3 heartbeats now will translate into 3 little ones in a few months time. So this is a story of hope, tinged with reality, and a healthy dose of apprehension for the task ahead, and as such would make a great ATC or ME commentary. A reminder that life goes in spite of pending elections, and bloody wars half way around the world.

Comment for "Spirit and Body Willing: Sex Over Age 70"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Spirit and Body Willing: Sex Over Age 70

Respectful and engaging, this is a topic whose time, given the burgeoning ranks of retiring boomers, has definately come. The subject matter is dealt with directly and sensitively with several charismatic seniors, and a number of experts who talk matter of factly about the potential problems they face in approaching sexual relations. The music is perfect for the piece and conjures up the era in which these folk first found romance; ambient sound is used to great effect, perfectly capturing the atmosphere of nursing homes and the activities that go on there. What is most unsettling in this piece is the attitude of offspring who find their parents abiding sexuality rather insavoury. Makes one ponder the future, especially given the statistic that women outnumber men in nursing homes 10 to 1!

This piece would make an excellent compliment to any other half hour on ageing and retirement; the shorter segments would be a perfect kick-off to a call-in show on ageing too. All round a great piece of radio.

Comment for "Back From the Dead"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Back From the Dead

This piece puts me in mind of that scene in Pulp Fiction where john travolta has to plunge a giant needle in the heart of an overdosing uma thurman, seconds after which she miraculously comes around. That isn't exacly what is prescribed here, (fortunately injection into the arm is fine) but the collage of voices describing what did happen when they or a friend they were with overdosed, and how lives were saved is compelling. This is a fascinating story, cataloging the efforts of the Chicago Recovery Alliance (bless them) who are trying to help heroin addicts help other addicts from overdosing. The frightening statistic of 499 heroin overdose deaths in the year 2000 in cook county, reinforces the desparate need for their work, even if those saved don't necessarily get off the drug for good.

Comment for "The last wild place"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The last wild place

A thoughtful and touching interview with a wildlife afficionado: it catalogs his early experiences that inspired his later career choice as wildlife cinematographer, his fascination with wilderness species (including Big Foot!), and his thoughts about why we must protect the environment in the future. It starts a little slowly, but draws you in as it progresses, due to the subject's understated enthusiasm for the wild and it's inhabitants. The interview might have benefited from more air; a pause where he moves on to a new subject, whether music or wildlife sounds, to allow digestion of what is said. Nevertheless, this piece would make a good addition to an environment hour, but would need an outro as it ends rather abruptly.

Comment for "The Essence of Dick Cheney's RNC Speech"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Essence of Dick Cheney's RNC Speech

The producer has distilled Cheney's speech to a succession of every fear-inducing word and phrase he uttered at the RNC, interspersed with boohs and chants from the audience to good effect, and it is entertaining (assuming you are of a liberal persuasion!) That being said I am not sure what part of the broadcast day this might be appropriate for, as it is undeniably one-sided and partisan. This could certainly be used in a call-in show format to induce calls from outraged republicans......

Comment for "Celebrity Stupidity"

Caption: PRX default User image

Slackjawed Sheep - R - Us

I must admit to being totally in agreement with this curmudgeonly commentator about the celebrity-obsessed society that currently exists, both in the UK and over here. A reference to Schwartzenegger's election in California dates this piece slightly, but the point is well made. If you need a little light relief from the bad news and electioneering that dominates the news cycle at the moment this piece could be for you.

Comment for "Iraq Fatigue"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Iraq Fatigue

A somewhat controversial viewpoint from across the pond, but one that some listeners may well relate to, as this war blunders on. The commentator explores the possible impacts of a withdrawal from Iraq, and his weariness with the ongoing barrage of tragic news from the frontlines. The piece reflects the uncomfortable reality of a war fought somewhere else: the majority of the population safely ensconced over here, engrossed by the mundanities of regular life, whilst helplessly watching gruesome developments on 24 hour cable news.

Perfect for ATC or ME, and likely to elicit feedback, possibly of the "typical lily-livered lefty NPR material" kind.

Comment for "The Economist Swing State Reports: Arizona"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Economist Swing State Reports: Arizona

This piece is succinct and timely, and I would love to hear the entire series on my local public radio station. This overview of the state of play in the state of Arizona seems to cover all the bases, from historical perspectives to demographic shifts to political party activities. The tone is serious but not stodgy, leaving this listener eager to learn more about this swing state and the rest. Roll on November 2nd.....

Comment for "The Most Recorded Musician" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Most Recorded Musician (deleted)

This is a profile of the prolific drummer Hal Blaine.The wealth of music excepts provides the listener with a broad sampling of his work, and his words shed light on how he got where he is today. It is also pleasing to discover that being a fun person to be around (in addition to being a hard worker and musically talented) gets you places....

Comment for "Tift Merritt: In her own words"

Caption: PRX default User image

Drinking sherry with the angels

This is a fabulous series, providing the listener with enough information and music to get a good sense of the artist and whether you would like to hear more. In this particular case I know I want to hear more: Ms Merritt reveals her influences and some personal details, and talks about her passion for music in a real and simple way, at once demystifying the creative process AND revealing how complex it is. Perfect insert for ATC or ME.

Comment for "Cowboy Junkies: In their own words"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Cowboy Junkies: In their own words

I am fan of the Cowboy Junkies, but not a well-informed one, just so you know.... Even if I didn't like them these pieces provide a lovely insight into their music, and the relationship between the family members which appears close, very close, and full of mutual respect; this latter fact makes me like them all the more. I am not sure I detected the difference between versions 1 and 2, but 3 is a minute shorter if time is limited. Whichever one you choose, choose one; each would sit perfectly in ATC or ME, and feature enough music excerpts to get a good feel for their style. As noted they are touring currently so an upcoming local appearance could provide a good hook.

Comment for "First Moment of Freedom"

Caption: PRX default User image

Life on the Outs

A collage of voices, some hopeful, some not, musing over the prospect of getting out of prison. Most seem to have a new found respect for family, and the simple things that make up a day, spending time with siblings, dressing how you want to, choosing when you eat etc. Unfortunately it is rare to hear from young voices like these anywhere, including public radio, which is a shame; this series could remedy that, at least a little bit, as it provides great material to build a talk show around.

Comment for "A Picture of Freedom from Behind Bars"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of A Picture of Freedom from Behind Bars

This piece is short and punchy, the question "what is freedom" elicits a broad range of answers, sandwiched between the harsh metallic slamming of prison doors. It offers hope for the future and cause for concern, and provides an insight into the lives of adolescents living behind bars, where the simplest of things that we, on the outside, take for granted are denied. This could make a thought-provoking addition to any show on troubled youth.

Comment for "Frank Sabatino, Fisherman"

Caption: PRX default User image

small head, big ocean....

This is a satisfying slice of life piece, that would be a welcome addition to any show with a maritime theme, and a surefire crowd pleaser if aired on coastal public radio stations. It is replete with salty language, interesting facts, and a taste of the sad realities of the declining fishing industry. My only criticism, and it is small (and really a compliment as it reflects some masterful mixing!) is that it just doesn't seem noisy enough, windy enough, engine-rumbly enough! I know engine noise is the bane of a radio producer's existence but, I have been on a few boats, and this was a quiet one. That being said, I am left pondering this incredible image, and what an image; "when it's just your head sticking up out of the ocean, it's a big ocean" Clearly the sinking of his boat had a lasting impact on Frank, not big enough to turn him away from his life's passion though.

Comment for "Thank-You Note"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Thank-You Note

I felt all anxious as I sat listening, eavesdropping, on this scene of domestic non-bliss, which must mean it rings true. I would think that most everyone can relate to this type of family bickering about seemingly small things disguising larger issues. Given it's length, it could easily be inserted into broadcast day, but to what aim I am not entirely sure. Perhaps by hearing this piece, over breakfast, it might give pause to family members trapped in these ongoing battles, or at least provide comfort, in showing we all go through similar ups and downs. Either way it is engaging and well executed, and provides much food for thought.

Comment for "Naked Barbies and Deflated Basketballs: A look inside the world of collectors"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Naked Barbies and Deflated Basketballs: A look inside the wo

This piece has received several, almost universally positive vox pop reviews, the snappy title could have been the draw, but the main reason is that this is a great piece. It is a lovely vox pop account of what makes collectors tick, it goes by way quicker than the 6 or so minutes it lasts, and has some great musical scoring. This is part confessional, part portrait and a lot of good listening, and best of all it is tender and respectful in its treatment of the subjects.

Comment for "Personals"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Personals

First, there is a second or so of audio at the beginning of this piece, just before the music starts, that shouldn't be there; and also this listener is a little confused (and pedantic I guess) as the intro talks about 2 upcoming personal ads, and then 3 follow. That being said this piece comprises too much of the ads (from a few lonely people whose only sin is trying to find a date), with not enough input from the narrator, even though the latter is a tad judgmental, in my humble opinion.

Comment for "Oppression is Forever: DeBeers Diamonds Spoof"

Caption: PRX default User image

Diamonds aren't a girl's best friend...

As a TV viewer, this ad campaign never fails to REALLY piss me off; it is manipulative, shallow, makes guys think that some crappy, exhorbitantly priced bauble is the key to a happy marriage, and many other things that prx politesse prevents me from typing. So i am glad that someone has taken it on, the music immediately brings the ad to mind, but I cant help feeling that the writing could have been pithier, to really skewer the brand like it deserves.

Comment for "Diet Coke"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Diet Coke

As a fellow immigrant, most everything in this commentary rings true, except the desire for diet coke, which thank god I still don't appreciate, with or without ice. The incremental changes in one's outlook, which go un-noticed most of the time, come into sharp focus during visits "home", and this piece describes this phenomena perfectly. Well-written and pithy, this essay is perfect for ATC or ME, or on a show focusing on immigration.