Comments by Erika Mahoney

Comment for "Why I Crew" (deleted)

User image

Review of Why I Crew (deleted)

Alex Foster's "Why I Crew" is a beautifully constructed audio piece. The acoustic music choice that ties the beginning to the end sets a peaceful mood for the entire piece. In addition, Alex Foster's soft voice really adds to the overall audio.

Being someone who has dedicated a lot of time to swimteam, I completely understand the perspective from which Alex is coming from. Alex's insight into how challenging yourself can lead to the appreciation of other things is profound and astute.

My only suggestion would be to edit in more space inbetween Alex Foster's narration to allow more time for the listener to digest what he/she just heard.

Comment for "Making It Out of High School"

User image

Review of Making It Out of High School

"Making it out of high school" is a vox pop about what student's plan to do with their lives after their senior year. It was interesting to hear all of the different plans and suprisingly, there was a huge variety. While one kid said they were going to college, the next said they wanted to be a hobo.

I really enjoyed listening to this piece because the different voice clips really flowed well together. It is difficult to edit a piece and not make it choppy when you have a lot of different voices, but the producer didn't have any problems with this.

Comment for "Watching My Cousin Sink Into Gang Life"

User image

Review of Watching My Cousin Sink Into Gang Life

"Watching my cousin sink into gang life" by Julie Piludo offers an outsider's view on gang life. The audio proves that bad things can happen to good people and illustrates how joining a gang can affect those not even directly involved. In the end, Julie does lose her cousin to jail, but she never forgets his advice.

Julie Piludo's voice really makes the piece touching and real. The music at the end also improves the audio.

Comment for "Stress and How We Deal"

User image

Review of Stress and How We Deal

"Stress and How to Deal" is a piece that can relate to every teenager. At one point or another in our lives, we all feel like we could explode from stress. Luckily,"Stress and How to Deal" not only reassures listeners that everyone is in the same boat, but also that there are ways to relieve the stress. From lists to sleep to getting excircise, many great tips for relieving stress are provided.

One of my favorite parts about this piece is all of the voices it encompasses; it really hooks the listener from the beginning. I also love the song choice at the end because it leaves listeners feeling optimistic.

Comment for "Party Chinese People"

User image

Review of Party Chinese People

"Party Chinese People" is an honest and interesting piece about Chinese assimilation into the United States. Pui Chau discusses the typical Chinese stereotypes but then begins to question them when she hears some Chinese kids partying in the house below her. She wonders whether these kids are revamping their morals or are simply trying to fit into the "American culture."

The background noises in this piece definitely enhance the overall audio. I like the topic and I like the questions "Party Chinese People" raises.

Comment for "Making It To School"

User image

Review of Making It To School

This witty piece takes a humorous look at the troubles of making it to school on time. The narrator has a tardy problem and takes it upon herself to get to the bottom of it. She interviews students and teachers at her school about tardy policies and the reasons behind tardiness. She also takes a close look at her daily morning and only then is able to solve the mystery.

The topic of this piece is what really makes it interesting and fun to listen to. The incorporation of background noises and interviews from other students/teachers really adds to the overall audio.

Comment for "Losing a Friend to AIDS"

User image

Review of Losing a Friend to AIDS

"Losing a Friend to AIDS" is a short, but powerful piece. When the narrator finds out her friend has the possibility of getting infected with HIV, her minds flashes back to an old friend whom she saw lose the fight to the disease.

The narrator does a great job of portraying how dangerous AIDS is and how at the same time is so easy to contract.

I really enjoyed listening to this piece because you could hear the emotion in the narrator's voice. She incorporates tiny details of her life along with metaphors that really make the listener want to listen. My only suggestion? Some soft music really would have brought it home.

Comment for "My Name Is Ryan"

User image

Review of My Name Is Ryan

"My Name is Ryan" is a captivating piece about drug addiction. Ryan discusses his past life and how every minute of it revolved around finding drugs, or using them. At the same time however, Ryan was able to warn others about drug addiction. He talks about how he had gotten disgustingly thin and how he had to roam the streets every night to find somewhere to sleep. These examples showed the true side of drug addiction.

I really enjoyed listening to the narrator's voice - he was calm and his words were almost soothing, proving he has the ability to start over. His music choice was good and it didn't distract listeners or take away from the narration.

Comment for "Homeschooling Dance Party"

User image

Review of Homeschooling Dance Party

For a long time, students, kids, and adults have pondered over the differences between kids who grow up going to school and those who learn at home. Hillary Frank digs deep into these issues questiong homeschooling kids about their daily lives at a homeschooling convention. And through this investigation, a lot of great points on the controversy are brought up. My favorite point that she made was that it appeared to her that homeschooled kids strive just as hard to be different as kids who go to school strive to be the same.

I really liked how this piece was put together. The background noise and music really brought the listener into the scene and I felt as if I was actually at the convention and the dance. Plus, Frank's questions for the homeschooled students were well thought out and I give her a lot of credit for being brave enough to question their ideas on the superiority of homeschooling.

Comment for "Speaking to My Heart"

User image

Review of Speaking to My Heart

"Speaking to My Heart" is a well done piece about teen pregnancy. In this piece, the narrator reveals just how difficult it is to find the balance between being an adult and being a teenager when you have kids of your own to raise. And although the narrator does make the mistake of leaning more towards her teenage life and ends up having to serve time in jail, she does realize her mistake and promises to be a better mother. I appreciate this message the piece carries because it gives hope to those who are in the same situation confirming that other teen mothers are fighting to make positive lifestyle changes as well.

One of my favorite parts about this piece was the beautiful music choice. The music was soft and pretty and complimented the narrator's voice very well. Furthermore, the kids audio clips of short conversations with their mother really added to the piece and made it that much more personal and real.

Comment for "Students' Rights: Then and Now"

User image

Review of Students' Rights: Then and Now

I really enjoyed listening to this expository piece by Charlie Thaxton. It was interesting how he juxtaposed a historical Supreme Court trial on student's rights with the present situation in the United States. By making this connection to the present, readers can take something away from this piece because even if we may have not lived during the Tinker vs. Demoine School District trial, we can understand the role it plays for students today.

One of my favorite parts about the piece was the sound byte that began the entire audio clip. This sound byte came from the Tinker vs. Demoine School District trial and it really set the tone for the rest of the piece. My only advice is that while I was listening to Charlie's narration, I hoped another sound byte, maybe from the recent trial that he described, would be brought in again.

Comment for "We Are Lane One"

User image

Review of We Are Lane One

Since the beginning of history, sports have defined people both athletically and characteristically. In "We Are Lane One," Emily LaFont shares her experience as a new member of the swim team. She details how hesitant she was at joining the team since she had never competitively swum before and frankly wasn't that good. Although she doesn't break any swimming records that season - she learned a lot about herself.

This radio piece about being the weakest link on a team is humorous and engaging while at the same time informative. We learn that everyone has a role on a team, even if that means cheering on the other athletes.

Even though this piece held my attention until the end, some background music or swimming pool sounds could have added a nice touch.

Comment for ""I Still Love Him...Oh Well.""

User image

Review of "I Still Love Him...Oh Well."

Adriana Martinez's piece "I Still Love Him...Oh Well" explores father - daughter relationships informing listeners that fathers are an irreplaceable part of a girl's life. Adriana tells listeners about her father and how he chose to pursue money over love for his daughter and wife. This decision had permanent consequences, and now in jail for drug dealing, he not only lost his freedom but also his daughter. Adriana reminisces on the absence of her father at her National Honor Society induction and how she missed his presence. This induction was an important part of her life because it marked her academic achievements and her father's absence profoundly affected her. But Adriana learns to get by; she adapts to her new life without a father and understands that that was solely his choice. In the end, she admits that he will always be her father and even though he chose drugs over her, she still loves him simply because he is her dad.

Adriana's clear voice carries the weight of her emotions surrounding her family situation pulling listeners into her raw feelings. Furthermore, her words touch on a very sensitive topic making this piece something everyone, and especially fathers and daughters, should hear.

Things to Notice: While Adriana Martinez's pure voice conveys the emotions associated with her father's absence, I think that some soft music could have enhanced this piece and helped tell the story.