Comments by Carlos Maeda

Comment for "Interview with a Bikemonster"

User image

Review of Interview with a Bikemonster

A funny and interesting story. The choice of music brings this “bad boy” image into out minds, much like the image that a chopper gives us. The sense of accomplishment given by this piece makes us look at our own work and wonder if we feel the same way Eli does.
There are a few things that I feel need to be fixed. The narration sounds robotic and the intro reminiscent of a class syllabus. These small tidbits should have this piece ready for the air in no time.

Comment for "Finding My Ma"

User image

Review of Finding My Ma

A very sad and surprising story. The sequence of unfortunate events this mother has gone through makes us feel pity and sorrow for this woman, leaving her afraid of having further relationships as well as those her daughter is soon to experience. It’s good to know that our parents have gone through the same if not worse experiences that we’re going through now.

Comment for "Music in Retail Settings"

User image

Review of Music in Retail Settings

Though I am prompted to “gently criticize” my fellow youth, I don’t believe this piece is able to be aired at this point. I feel the piece’s topic is an interesting one but will need to be revised in order catch the audience’s attention. It honestly sounds like a rough draft. All the ideas are there, but they just need to be worked on.
There are quite a few technical problems that need to be fixed, like the addition of a few pauses and the cutting of the stuttering the narrator performs. At 3:16, there is a very long, dead pause that shouldn’t be there. The narrator should also use a slower tempo. His fast pace seems to throw me off, making me feel that this story is not one of importance, especially when put together with those of the interviewees. Also, I feel that the performance is a bit sketchy, sounding like the narrator is reading off a script.
A second trip to the recording studio with some of the tips given above should go a long way for this piece.

Comment for "Dressy Girls"

User image

Review of Dressy Girls

The producer leads us through this narrow path where the popular “in” kids are on one side and the “outsiders” are on the other. The interviews are funny and interesting, especially when “dressing like a skank” becomes the issue, bringing about stories that are gold. I loved how the producer used references from teenage magazines as well as how she attacks them, although this may cause a bit of a problem with some stations that may advertise those same magazines. Overall, however, I left with positive feeling about myself, overly lifting my self-esteem and making me feel comfortable in my trusty jeans.

Comment for "Teen Retail Psychology: Playing the Popularity Game at Work"

User image

Review of Teen Retail Psychology: Playing the Popularity Game at Work

We all have been "welcomed" by sales associate who want to be our friend at least once. Putting on a smile after being scolded by a fellow customer, holding the door open as you walk in, saying "have a great night" as you walk out of the store; we all know it's fake, but it's done none the less. Sophie did a good job bringing us back into that world, one where those interactions are included in your job description. The piece was well put and easy to flow with. I loved how Sophie noticed and explained the "lying" that occured during her interview. There was a good connection between her fellow teenagers and the informative scholar. I loved how she brought in the scholar right after an interviewee and followed it up with a hard working teenager. It worked well to show us that not all teenagers have their daddy's plastic at their disposal.

Comment for "College for the Undocumented"

User image

Review of College for the Undocumented

Very inspirational. Sanchez is able to capture your mind and collide it with his, being able to show us not just how difficult it is for an undocumented student to be admitted into college, but the mental struggle with themselves to continue trying. Sanchez did a good job structuring the piece, placing good interview subjects in the right places. The sense hope at the end is a great positive to a piece full of despiration and futility.

Comment for "Mic Check: What Are You Doing for Halloween?" (deleted)

User image

Review of Mic Check: What Are You Doing for Halloween? (deleted)

A sarcastic spin on a teen's Halloween night. I loved the humorous tone the narrator had in his voice. The music used fits together with the story like a puzzle. The producer was able to get away with opening up with "Thriller" The other sound bits brought out the mischief that most youth experience on this wonderful holiday. The interviews were tight and weaved together great so that the audience could flow with it. All in all, Great Piece. I laughted hard.

Comment for "A City Bigger Than"

User image

Review of A City Bigger Than

Warren Polk did an outstanding job writing this poem. His attack on the city's "Hollywood" depiction is nothing short of inspiring. His delivery is precise and his understanding of the city's history is very accurate. Polk describes both the ups and downs of living in a large and overpopulated urban environment, and shows us that Chicago deserves a deeper look than your usual stereotypes.

Comment for "Oakland Scenes: Snapshots of a Community"

User image

Review of Oakland Scenes: Snapshots of a Community

The story’s topic is unfortunately becoming more and more of a problem in our world. The piece’s modern twist on Romeo & Juliet brings our generation’s problem into focus. The first things that hit you are the rhymes of a poet, the perfect way to complement Shakespeare. His words are serious as well as comical, even bringing our slang under the microscope. The interviews are real and detailed, and strike us with its intense drama. It basically mixes a poetry slam with a soap-opera, which only emphasizes this story's seriousness even more. This well structured piece would be a great collection to any radio station's playlist.

Comment for "Obesity"

User image

Review of Obesity

Obesity is a very "touchy" subject in today's youth, especially American youth. "Why am I the only one here?" brings humor to the dreaded question of: Why aren’t there more obese teenagers in the gym? The narrator makes use of the statistics gathered without causing the youth audience to fall dead in their tracks for listening to a broken record. The story’s structure is well put and informative. In all, the humorous intro and outro, the strong structure, and the interviewees make this piece one to be heard by everyone in our generation.

Comment for "Aspiring Teen Musicians"

User image

Review of Aspiring Teen Musicians

The audio I just listened to deals with a growing problem in our generation...society telling youth how to be ourselves. The piece talks about the struggle for a youth to make their music into a career, and how today's culture puts limits on the musicians in order to see a glimpse of success. There previews of "tomorrow's artists" in the piece which are considerably good. The structure is strong and the piece is entertaining, especially when some of the interviewees actually perform for the microphone; good audio throughout. Overall, I felt compelled to pick up my guitar and jam just for the heck of it, not to impress the girl next door or to get signed by a label, but just to make myself feel good, and that's this piece is all about.

Comment for "Starting College...Again"

User image

Review of Starting College...Again

Andre seems like a normal guy, not one who just lost their home. The piece has a good story on how the taxi driver got him to the airport in time and in turn, saved his life. I liked how Andre interviewed other evecuees on their thoughts and feelings. Jonathan seemed to have everything go wrong with his bus catching on fire. I can also relate to his doubt in coping with a school of a large size. I, myself, went from a graduating class of 40 to a class of 857 when entering high school. I liked how Christopher puts the hurricane in perspective when he said, "It's just mother nature...you can't stop her," because you can't and that makes the audience feel helpless. Finally, when Andre described New Orleans after the hurricane as a "ghost town", a somber tone appears; maybe he has thoughts about not returning, after all, he's "Unsure".