Comments by Bill McKibben

Comment for "Deep In Our Hearts"

User image

Review of Deep In Our Hearts

There's been a lot of radio done about the civil rights movement--but this is a very special piece of work. These women were not exactly "leaders" of the student movement in th e South, which makes the piece much better; you get a sense of what it really felt like. And the producers make the good choice of all but ignoring the 'emergence-of-feminism' story and the 'interracial sex' story, both of which have been told before. Instead, we get a real feel of what it felt like in Alabama and Mississippi in those years. Which may be the single most compelling story in all of American history.

Comment for "Little Gray Book Lecture: How to Communicate Without the Use of Wires"

User image

Review of Little Gray Book Lecture: How to Communicate Without the Use

Two good stories in hre--the dad searching for aliens, and the ghost haunting the Ramada. I'm not quite as convinced by all the apparatus around them--the endless tee-heeing of the audience is a bit distracting--but these are excelolent storytellers. If you like Spaulding Gray...

Comment for "Thurgood Marshall Before the Court" (deleted)

User image

Review of Thurgood Marshall Before the Court (deleted)

An important piece of radio history, does a superb job of capturing the lesser known early years of the Marhsall civil rights crusade--the all night legal gatherings at NAACP HQ, the search for cases that would work as fundraisers as well as vehicles for change, the sense of moment that surrounded Brown V. Board. The only sadness is how little tapea there is of Marshall--the one snippet of him telling a story at a dinner is priceless

Comment for "The Creative Remix"

User image

Review of The Creative Remix

I could keep going with the adjectives. Like, smart: this piece actually offers a new take on the world. Many things will strike you a little differently once you've heard it. And the decision to avoid lawyers may be the smartest part, since that't the one and only thing that, say, ATC would focus on if they did this story. This is a great piece about art in the present moment!

Comment for "Sunset Hall"

User image

Review of Sunset Hall

If, as someone once said, a 20-year-old who isn't a socialist has no heart and a 40 year old who is a socialist has no head, what can you say about an 80-year-old who has never wavered for a moment? That they have no teeth, probably, and that they live at Sunset Hall. This is a lovely piece; it would have been easy to make fun of these guys, and easy to be sentimental about them, but this avoids both pitfalls. A real testament to appealing crankiness!

Comment for "With God On Our Side: From Rivalry To Reconciliation"

User image

Review of With God On Our Side: From Rivalry To Reconciliation

This is an extremely important piece of radio, and one that should be widely heard. It geats at an absolutely central question: under what circumstances can these faiths reach some kind of intellectual accomodation? the stories are wonderful, especially of Muslim-Jewish rapprochement in America. My only caveat is: the Christian representative is perhaps not altogether or even very representative of the current state of American Christianity, and hence the real dogmatism is only tangentially engaged. But an excellent and brave start!

Comment for "Mme. Blavatsky and The Colonel Part One"

User image

Review of Mme. Blavatsky and The Colonel Part One

This is a story everyone needs to hear, since it sheds actual light on the endless fascination with the occult. TShe story of Madame Blavatsky, Col. Alcott, and all that it led to is told with economy, grace, and real style, and the ending of Part Two is the only possible ending, absolutely perfect. I have no idea how this reporter becomes authoritative on such a wide variety of subjects, but I'm awfully glad she does. There is a modesty about these pieces that belies theair authority

Comment for "Little Odessa in Brooklyn"

User image

Review of Little Odessa in Brooklyn

I'm not sure I've ever heard anyone who does this history-on-the-radio any better. The reporting and the thinking are both keen, and thes sense of how much sound, how long a clip--wow, this is professional in the very best sense of the word. What an intriguing place to describe, right back to the early days of the great hotels.

Comment for "Chasing Love"

User image

Review of Chasing Love

What a fresh and interesting piece of radio. It's written and produced with real thought--though I didn't think the word salad interludes were as effective as the declarations that make up most of the piece. And the last part, when we reallyt got to late capitalism and love, is a mind-opener. A perfect late-evening piece.

Comment for "The Afro: Personal Reflections" (deleted)

User image

Review of The Afro: Personal Reflections (deleted)

The first ten minutes of this was pretty dismal, I thought--a kind of expert roundup of obvious and overly authoritative opining on the emergence of the afro. I mean, do we really need Alvin Poussaint on this? And there was plenty of repetition all the way through, as one entertainer after another told essentially the same story about discovering the natural. But you know what? it got stronger and stronger as it went on, the voices deeper and richer. Still--given that there was an hour to fill, what about a few words from a barber? What about the phenomenon of the white afro (that guy on Room 222--what was that all about?). A little more street-level stuff would have given this piece some air--but it's a deserving work, and one that will give younger listeners a concise and interesting history lesson.

Comment for "Teen Retail Psychology: Playing the Popularity Game at Work"

User image

Review of Teen Retail Psychology: Playing the Popularity Game at Work

This is really fine work, and really interesting too. In fact, it owuld be a lot better if it was a lot longer--there is a realy Fast Times at Ridgemont High story to be told here, about clothes stores instead of fast food places. Give us a half hour on it!

Comment for "Biography of 100,000 Square Feet"

User image

Review of Biography of 100,000 Square Feet

This is truly great work. There were hundreds of places where the author could have taken short cuts, emerged with easy epiphanies. he avoided them all, and he's given city dwellers everywhere a really important text for refelecting on how planning gets done. And there is a wildly revealing moment when he's interviewing the landscape architect behind this mess--you hear the voice of undemocratic "expertise" ring out in all its unguarded clarity. A bravura piece of urban reporting and political thinking, jsut the right length.

Comment for "The Tomato and The Big Apple"

User image

Review of The Tomato and The Big Apple

Do you like shaggy dog stories? I do, and this is a great one. Following a tomato in its journey back to New York is only a semi-interesting conceit, but the stories that go along with it are magnificent--especially the pugilistic truck driver, who is a latter-day Damon Runyon character. If you know Joe Mitchell's finest work (and if you don't, you have a treat in store) you will realize the tradition of New York stories to which this belongs. A few more facts might have been helpful--like how much of these biosolids are actually used--but what the hell. This is a very fine piece, from a mind that will clearly produce much more of value. I can't wait.

Comment for "Where Coffee Rituals Go to Die"

User image

Review of Where Coffee Rituals Go to Die

Quite a nice piece--it really recreates the atmosphere of a place as best one can, once it's dead and gone. And tht's the only flaw here. Somehow the structure of the whole thing doesn't quite work--you need to know before the last minute or two that it burned down, i think. but a sweet piece, nostalgic but in an easy key

Comment for "WNYC's Fishko Files: An Hour With Dave Brubeck"

User image

Review of An Hour With Dave Brubeck

Jeez, this is one they should hand to the new radio recruits as they report for duty. The pacing is spot-on perfect--the proportion of words to notes somehow works wonderfully. More, the host is as laidback and easygoing, yet smart, as Brubeck's classic works. She's jsut enough of the piece, never too much. I can't imagine any station format where this wouldn't fit in the evening. You could say she softballed him a little bit--nothing on the question of whether black musicians resented his Time cover, etc--but what the hell, that's all been covered, he's an old guy (though still right there), and in the end it's such a treat to see his music and his personality blend together.

Comment for "RN Documentary: She-wood & Cypress - The Mississippi River Rats"

User image

Review of RN Documentary: She-wood & Cypress: The Mississippi River Ra

A nice piece, full of good voices, redolent with interesting social history. The interviewer is too concerned with exact terminology--keeps asking 'did they call them river rats?' as if that matters--and steers too clear of the present day. but other than that, a relaxing and thoughtful piece, and well worth it for the closing bit where one of these river dwellers comments on his local npr station!

Comment for "World Vision Report - Show 55 - Air Date - 013005" (deleted)

User image

Review of World Vision Report - Show 55 - Air Date - 013005 (deleted)

World Vision does good work in many places--i've come across their people in a variety of developing countries. That said, this is not entirely neutral reporting. It comes from an avowedly Christian group that gets most of thier support from middle to right-of-middle American Christians. You can perhaps hear a few echoes of that in their "coverage" of the war in Iraq that opens this segment, for instance. There's nothing really out-of-kilter here, (and as a longtime Sunday School teacher its stance doesn't bother me much) but programmers should be aware that this is not a typical news source. The radio is straightforward, tending a mite towards the dull end of the spectrum.

Comment for "Seeing Red: Marshalling Cultural Anger in Middle America" (deleted)

User image

Review of Seeing Red: Marshalling Cultural Anger in Middle America (deleted)

Thomas Frank is in rare form here--one of the msot interesting thinkers in the country today, in full, funny, under-control, fire-hose powerful rant. The only problem with this piece is that it ends much too abruptly, and just as he's beginning to make an important point. Still, his voice (and mind) is powerful enough to carry the whole thing.

Comment for "Tossing Away the Keys"

User image

Review of Tossing Away the Keys

This is a great piece of radio, one of the finest half hours around. I remember it when it was first broadcast, and now would be the perfect moment for stations to replay it. It's an almost unbelievably sad and powerful story. But they'll need to have an intro (or maybe better a new ending) a couple of minutes long to explain how it was that Rideau finally managed to get out. It would also work very well with coverage of Sister Helen prejean's new book on the death penalty. (She and Rideau are old friends). Anyway, what a piece!

Comment for "Peace Talks Radio: Martin Luther King Jr.'s Path To Nonviolence (59:00/54:00)"

User image

Review of Martin Luther King Jr.'s Path To Nonviolence (59:00 Version)

The first half of this show--the interview with Doroty Cotton, Dr. King's assistant at the Southern Christian Leadership Conference--is really wonderful.
The second half is less so--King's daughter Yolanda has become a 'motivational speaker,' and she speaks with all the shallowness one would expect from a practitioner in that field. Also, the focus on nonviolence gets lost--and a deep, in-depth disucssion of nonviolence is deeply necessary at the moment--especially some way of trying to comparae how King dealth with Vietnam and how we are dealing with Iraq at the moment. . But what works best in this show, of course, is the chance to listen to Dr. King, in several long excerpts from his speeches. I believe there may be a half-hour version of this featuring jsut Dorothy Cotton's interview, and I think that would be a fine piece to play at almost any time, not just Dr. King's birthday

Comment for "Written in My Soul from Me to You: Blood on the Tracks at 30"

User image

Review of Written in My Soul from Me to You: Blood on the Tracks at 30

This is really a classic piece of radio work. First off, it sounds gorgeous--thank heaven the producers opted for two hours so they could play the whole songs, keep the pace so casual and easy. The whole thing breathes. Second, there's just enough history, just enough current appreciation, jsut enough Greil Marcus being his usual brilliant self. You end up feeling as if your mind has been stretched, as if you've been helped to make interesting connections. For anyone of this vintage, it's compelling, a perfect piece to stretch out on the sofa and listen to in the twilight, wineglass dangling in your hand.

Comment for "It's a Pan Peninsula"

User image

Review of It's a Pan Peninsula

What a wonderfuol piece of radio--infectiously joyful, just like the music it chronicles. The producers have a natural sense of pace, and they answer all the questions you want answered at jsut the right spot. a perfect choice of topic--who'd a thunk it, all those laconic Mainers rocking out behind the pans?

Comment for "The Role Of State Government In Creating An Ethical Business Climate."

User image

Review of The Role Of State Government In Creating An Ethical Business

The general case: Chautauqua lectures are serious and useful, long enough to get at something, and they're not obsessed (a la the commonwealth club etc) with having the most powerful folks around.

The specific case: This is an enormously powerful talk by Spitzer, who is possibly the brightest and msot interesting public official in america. He speaks rigorously, clearly, and completely without condescension. A wonderful talk, despite the lame title. Spitzer/Obama in 2012!

Comment for "Saul and Joshua"

User image

Review of Saul and Joshua

a fine, and slightly eerie and mysterious, piece of work, a real portrait of an unusual friendship and a difficult way of life. you will think differently about musical panhandlers once you've heard it. first rate for any urban station.

Comment for "Art of the Song #10 with Nanci Griffith & Tom Russell" (deleted)

User image

Review of Art of the Song with Nanci Griffith & Tom Russell (deleted)

I've listened to several of these "art of the song" shows now, though this is the first i've reviewed. I think they are aabsolutely top notch, and can't imagine they're not on most public radio stations. The interviews are good (mostly because they pick good people to interview, which is the only real secret to interviewing). But they also get out of the way and let people talk. along the same lines, they get out of the way and let people sing--they use whole cuts of songs, not a single chorus or verse. Cretivity is a vexedly difficult topic to capture, but this does it better than just about anything i've heard on the radio. Really really solid. And Nanci Griffith is great fun to listen to. "Every song of mine has at least one line in it tht states my politics and my social views." Good enough for me

Comment for "Dog Park: Jason, the Cheap #@*%!"

User image

Review of Jason, the Cheap #@*%!

Great and telling interview, which might actually make someone give some money. The sound gets a little lsot in the last forty seconds--I'd jsut end it with jake talking and go right back to the get smart theme. Oh, and I'd say what kind of dog the guy has

Comment for "Return to Israel"

User image

Review of Return to Israel

A good, straightforward take on what it actually feels like to live in Israel in a time of terror. But it doesn't go deep enough--it starts to get there with the woman who's talking about yelling at her kids because she's scared. You want to hear questions that are less general. (And of course you want to hear about those people across the wall who are living in an even tougher place, at an even tougher time--but that's for another day and another piece)

Comment for "Disney Death"

User image

Review of Disney Death

Little boy Walt Disney killed an owl? Wow--this is wild stuff, the perfect use of radio, thinking about something we all have in common but from an entirely new angle. it really lets you understand the icky sentimental nature of everything Disney, not to mention its undeniable appeal. it also asks questions about death in our culture that I haven't quite heard asked before. Only one question here--isn't it "hydrophobia," not "hydrophobie"?

Comment for "Owning Guns"

User image

Review of Owning Guns

In the wake of the election, somehow pieces that are about ambiguity seem extremely important--like, isn't there a bit of red state in all of us? In this narrator to be sure, and it's brought out very nicely. I wish the piece had been longer, is all--there are stories (his boyhood friend, his own kids, the European friends) that seem half-told here.

Comment for "Pop Vultures #11: Tupac Shakur & Folk Sleazeballs" (deleted)

User image

Review of Pop Vultures #11: Tupac Shakur & Folk Sleazeballs (deleted)

just another example of why this program should be on the air all the time. I mean, Tupac must be one of the most important artists of our time, but I doubt his music ever appears on more than 1% of public stations. I wish there'd been a tiny bit more of it here--in fact, a whole half hour on Tupac would have been welcome, and so in fact would a half hour on why dave matthews is so bad. as it is, there's no real transition between the two segments, which is probably too much to ask of a public radio audience who will be struggling to identify either one