Comments by Ben Adair

Comment for "Footlight Parade: First Meetings (FP06:51)" (deleted)

User image

Review of Footlight Parade: First Meetings (FP06:51) (deleted)

Footlight Parade is basically a good excuse to listen to some of the best and most classic songs from over a century of American musicals. This program is based around when famous characters meet and while it's not going to grab on to listeners who don't care for musicals in general, and make new fans (I count myself among this group), I think anyone hearing it will be singing along at some point or another ("I Could Write a Book" got me at about 15 minutes in). The production values are great -- the musical numbers sound perfect-- and it's really nice to hear the full songs.

This show or series would sound great on a weekend evening or night. I like that the host basically sticks with his short, pungent intros and outros so we can back to the music as soon as possible. One thing I would have appreciated that this episode doesn't do would be to have some representation of newer, more alternative musicals -- for example some Robert Wilson or Stephen Trask songs.

Comment for "Andy and Dirk"

User image

Review of Andy and Dirk

This is a fun, interesting story about highschool rivalries in a small town. The narrator has one of those deep, resonant radio voices that almost makes you pay attention and the story keeps moving with its plot about cowboys, headbangers and jocks vying for the title of coolest and toughest in school.

The only thing missing from this piece -- and it is just barely missing -- is that finally sentence or two at the end that universalizes the experience and forces the piece to transcend its actual subject and be about something more, something bigger. That twist would make this piece appropriate for any major show or time. As it is, however, it would fit great anywhere people are talking about kids or schools, violence in school, etc.

Comment for "Angel's Landing"

User image

Review of Angel's Landing [S.Carrier]

Scott Carrier's quick audio tour of Angel's Landing in Utah's Zion National Park is like a nice summer vacation in the middle of winter. The writing is fantastic, the voices varied and fun, the music and bird songs adding a really nice atmosphere. Listening to the piece gives me the same exhilaration that I think the people feel after making the climb. Only here I am, listening to the radio -- not so strenuous and none of the cardiovascular benefits.

This piece will play great as winter turns to spring and people in your area start thinking about going outside again. If you're going to do a talk show about hikes or domestic summer vacations, it'd be a nice way to break from your guests and give a little experiential radio to your listeners.

Comment for "JW on Judd"

User image

Review of JW on Judd

What a funny and wonderful piece of tape this is.

For those who don't know, Marfa, TX is a West Texas, middle of nowhere town made world famous when a conceptual artist came town and created a center for large scale conceptual art. In this tape, which sounds a bit too raw, a bit too rambly and a bit too long to air at this point, a local good old boy gives a fascinatingly sophisticated critique of the fancy art (and artists) that have come to town.

This piece is surprising and funny and says more about cultural stereotypes (of high AND low) in a few minutes than most reporters will say all year. But it does need some editing and work before it can get to air.

Comment for "Block Party"

User image

Review of Block Party

Eve Abrams' exploration into a Brooklyn neighborhood's block party provides a chance to hear some of the interesting slice of life stories that define a neighborhood. There's a good diversity of voices here: young, old, lots of different accents and some nice, heartwarming anecdotes. Sounds like a nice place to spend an afternoon.

This piece has a distinctly summer air about it. It would fit nicely on a show about neighbors or even ethnic diversity and community. The accents give a very distinctly New York feel to it, but the issues and conflicts are applicable to any urban neighborhood, I think.

Comment for "A Bosnian Christmas Carol"

User image

Review of A Bosnian Christmas Carol

This is an interesting piece about Christmas in a foreign land -- the strange traditions which inspire both laughter and tears, the intimate connections made with strangers and old friends alike, and the suprising feelings that come from spending time in a war ravaged land. This is a personal piece, told in first person by a reporter visiting his family, so it would make sense in a magazine style show or any program that would value a unique, individual take on the holidays.

I was a bit turned off by the initial "wacky holiday celebrations!" take that predominates the first half of the piece -- it feels extremely trite when the narrator tells us to ignore the whole history of the Bosnian war. But by the end of the story, as the reporter embraces the full emotional impact that war can have on Christmas and on a community, the story goes to a new level worthy of the holiday it's celebrating.

Comment for "Anywhere But Now"

User image

Review of Anywhere But Now

This 14+ minute personal essay does threaten to go off track from time to time but I was suprised at its ablity to snap back with enough twists and turns and actual suprises to make the self-aware narrator's navel-gazing funny, intelligent and, in the end, worth it. It's a refreshing take on a well-trod topic and could find a nice home on any station with a good-sized college audience or during graduation time. The mix of essay with tape and sound effects / music works well.

Comment for "Final Exit"

User image

Review of Final Exit

A blend of great writing and music, this piece by Kelly McEvers puts a very personal and engaging spin on assisted suicide and the "right to die" movement. This is, in fact, a perfect example of what first person radio essays are supposed to be: personal and universal, funny and sad -- overall, very thoughtful: showing me why this issue is important and leading me think hard about it without a hint of preachy-ness, over-writing or ham-handed conclusions.

This piece would sound great on a show like ATC (I'm sort of wondering why they haven't picked it up already), or dropped into ATC on a local station. It says it's timely for New Years but could be played anytime of the year, really.

Comment for ""The Cairo Trilogy" by Naguib Mahfouz"

User image

Review of "The Cairo Trilogy" by Naguib Mahfouz

Despite the horrible pun setting up this show about Nagib Mafouz ("Nagib Mafouz has died, leaving behind a body -- of work ..."), this is an important piece of radio, especially these days when examples of an Arabic intellectual tradition are far over-shadowed by the terrorist threat and Muslim extremism. What Radio Netherlands has put together here -- a hybrid of interview, scored readings and reported feature -- is a great introduction to Nagib Mafouz, the ideas behind his most famous works and the underpinnings of the rich cultural tradition he belongs to. It would fit great in any slot meant for books or culture in general.

Comment for "Crossing East: Shasta Taiko"

User image

Review of Crossing East: Shasta Taiko

This is an interesting piece about the roots of an ancient Japanese music in America -- including the important cultural milleu that spawned it and how it's grown up. The music underneath is great and you get a real sense of the important mission for the players and how the music becomes fills a cultural need for those who hear it. This piece would fit well dropped into ATC or ME, or anywhere a good music piece is desired.

Comment for "Pink & Yellow" (deleted)

User image

Review of Pink & Yellow (deleted)

This is an interesting idea -- I'm generally very interested in anything synesthetic -- but this goes on a bit too long. I hesitate to think what a listener who missed the first few seconds (i.e. the intro) would think because the tones end up sounding a lot like the Emergency Broadcast System!

However, this would be a very fun piece at about 1/2 its length. A good way to pull listeners in with a "what the heck is that ... Oh, cool!" type approach.

Comment for "Radiolab, Show 205: Space"

User image

Review of Radio Lab, Show 205: Space

It's easy to get lost in something as big and vast as space itself. Even easier when you have to plan a whole hour going through it. And though this episode of Radio Lab does take a few "long cuts" and diverge into the realm of the "merely interesting" from time to time, overall the show presents as enjoyable an exploration of our fascination with outer space, our forays into it and our deepest questions -- philosophical, physical, mechanical -- about it.

And something interesting happens along the way. Amid all these voices, all these theories, the science fiction and the science fact, it became clear to me in listening to this episode of Radio Lab that the challenges we face in approaching, exploring and conquering space are the same ones we face here on earth -- in international politics, domestic affairs, even in our interpersonal relationships. These are questions of will and ambition; courage and fear; our own abilities as individuals and people to rise above the quotidian and do something great.

Comment for "The Frankenstein Family Crypt"

User image

Review of The Frankenstein Family Crypt

Don't listen to this piece expecting to be scared or frightened. What's interesting about this piece is that it becomes very clear in listening to it exactly how much more sophisticated we've become as media consumers; how much more we demand these days from our radio, our television and our movies.

Carl Nelson's abject fear, which the announcer assures us is genuine and caused a sensation across Europe, sounds almost quaint by our standards today. It's hard to believe that listeners would fall for this. But what this shows me is that our own expectations today -- what it would take to illicit any kind of emotional reaction -- are so much higher than they were 50 years ago. I don't necessarily read this as greater "sophistication" or anything like that. More like an emotional callousness that takes more and more shock, more and more drama to break through.

Comment for "Sound Artist Steve Peters: The Subtle Sounds of Nature"

User image

Review of Sound Artist Steve Peters: The Subtle Sounds of Nature

This piece is like ear candy for the hungry public radio listener. A sound artist walks us through some beautiful nature recordings he's made in the New Mexican desert. You hear the sound of a cactus, some ants, the sound of birds and a fence. Beautiful stuff. Ends with a nice sum up about how paying attention to our surroundings can greatly enrich our lives.

This piece has a nice fall feel to it. A station can program it into any slot for a longish-type feature -- an arts slot, for example, or just for a break from hard news / ax and trax type reporting. The sounds are really great.

Comment for "Kathmandu"

User image

Review of Kathmandu

Sujata Tuladhar's tale of becoming a DJ in Kathmandu is an interesting story of cultural conflict and experience, but ultimately left me scratching my head a little bit. On the one hand, yes this is an interesting story and would fit on any show that values pieces about cultural exchange or personal transformation, all done in a very specific NPR style.

But on the other hand, she was hosting an American country and western show in Kathmandu. To me, a story about why country music resonates in Nepal is a fascinating question that's never answered in this piece. it left me scratching my head thinking, what about that?

Well, regardless, Kathmandu is a nice piece.

Comment for ""What's your opinion of memory?""

User image

Review of "What's your opinion of memory?"

This is an engaging little radio play that's basically a quirky cocktail party conversation -- two people talking about "the power of memory" quickly reveal much more about themselves than either person is ready to handle. I guess it's actually the opposite of small talk. You expect the people to say nothing and instead you get a fascinating window into their interior world. It's well produced, written and acted. A great piece of radio.

This piece would fit well as an interstitial on a talk show -- a nice break from a host / guest back and forth. I could also hear it as an intro piece to a larger conversation. Adventurous programmers could use it as a stand-alone piece of radio theater.

Comment for "Wily Coyotes in the City"

User image

Review of Wily Coyotes in the City

Wily Coyotes in the City alerts us all to the growing problem of coyotes in American cities. Though this piece focuses on the Midwest, I live in Los Angeles and know that we have coyotes out here too. I've seen them. In fact, my girlfriend saw one take a kitty one day. It was horrible.

Anyway, this piece alerts us to the growing problem of coyotes in the city and what law enforcement and researchers are doing about it. It's an important topic and this piece would fit into any program about wildlife, the environment or community problems.

Comment for "Ayacucho"

User image

Review of Ayacucho

Ayacucho is a very interesting melding of personal essay and serious news documentary. The story centers on a town in Peru, the site of a massacre years before during the Peruvian civil war. Miguel Macias, the reporter / commentator explains the stakes, why the story is important to him and helps us understand why this story is important to the people of Peru and to us, as listeners.

It's a surprising take on an esoteric subject that works. Miguel's calm delivery and inquisitive nature guide us through the story in an engaging way. The tragedy becomes a universal struggle for dignity, small people standing up for themselves, which resonates across language and geographic boundaries.

This piece would fit into any slot set aside for international politics or politics in general. It has a laid back feel that would be equally comfortable during weekdays or weekends. I hope p.d.'s can find a place for it!

Comment for "RN Documentary: Lorenzo da Ponte"

User image

Review of RN Documentary: Lorenzo da Ponte

This Radio Netherland's 1/2-hour special on the lyricist Lorenzo da Ponte does about as much as you can with a basic hosted interview. The author who's interviewed, writer of a recent da Ponte biography, is very knowledgeable and clearly excited about his subject. He speaks in emotional tones, clearly amused, perplexed -- an excellent storyteller. The piece uses voiceovers and music in a very engaging way.

However, the piece still suffers from what ails most extended two-ways -- if you're not inherently interested in opera, Mozart or da Ponte, the piece does little to explain to you why you should be or why da Ponte is important. As for me, not being an opera fan, I never really got caught up in the piece.

This piece would fit great wherever an audience is hungry for well-produced conversation about classical music or opera.

Comment for "Occitan Rock"

User image

Review of Occitan Rock

Straightforward approach to an interesting subject -- I had never heard of Occitan and to learn about the language and its own poltical music was very interesting. The music is good and well recorded.

This piece would fit nicely in a "global beat" type segment or on any type of public radio music show.

Comment for "The Dog Plan"

User image

Review of The Dog Plan

I love radio and I love dogs. So hearing this episode of The Plan is like a dream come true. The stories are engaging, humorous, sentimental and sweet. It made me think about dogs and people and why we have such specials bonds with animals ... especially when it seems like those bonds between people are fewer and farther between.

The sound design is excellent and the pace of the show moves right along -- always engaging. For extra excitement, listen to this special with your dog and watch what happens when the barks and yelps reach fever pitch. It's interactive radio at its finest.

Not to get all cliche, but this episode of the plan does have a very summery feel to it. It would sound great on a weekend afternoon. This is a really great show that will pull your listeners to it.

Comment for "Heroin"

User image

Review of Heroin

A thoroughly engaging piece from Jenesse Nieves and Radio Rookies that inadvertently illustrates a key failure of the War on Drugs and Americans' attitudes toward drug users.

This piece has a very simple purpose: Janesse goes to interview her father about his life as a marginly-housed heroin addict. In the process, we find out about her relationship with her other family members, a little about drug addiction from an MD and about the role her father's addiction has played in Janesse's own life.

The climax of the piece comes when Janesse finally finds her father and immediately starts arguing with him about his addiction. Even though she knows better, her emotions take over and there's very little attempt at communion; Janesse's primary goal in this exchange -- to tell her father she loves him -- is overcome by her feelings of anger and betrayal. It's clear that this particular drug addict needs love and support, yet all Janesse can show him is wrath and spite.

This piece is taylor made for a magazine type radio show that wants to show a personal take on drug addiction. it would also be a great lead-in story for a local talk show's conversation of the day (or hour, or half-hour). It provides so much to talk about: drug addiction, the practices of harm reduction, being the friends and families of addicts, the rapidly failing War on Drugs, etc.

Comment for "RN Documentary: Night Frights"

User image

Review of RN Documentary: Night Frights

I was pleasantly surprised by this Radio Netherlands special on night paralysis and night frights. It starts off fairly typical and dry, but as soon as it goes to tape and people start talking about their dream experiences, I was hooked. The sound design -- mostly scary music and sound effects -- threatened to get cheesy, but instead worked throughout.

The bulk of the 29 minute show is an interview with a dream / brain scientist who's explaining what we know about dreams, nightmares and night paralysis (not very much, lots of speculation) and he's interesting enough. But the best part are people describing their horrible dreams and what they've been through. Creepy!

Also, towards the end, the doc talks about the cultural implications of these specific types of nightmares and that's fascinating. Surprisingly, however, there's very little discussion of the spiritual aspects of these types of night terrors.

This show would be great to program around Halloween. Or, if I were a program director, I'd put it on randomly at like 3:30 am -- just to let all those lying awake in terror know that they're not alone out there.

Comment for "THE COMEDY-O-RAMA "SUMMER ROAD TRIP" SPECIAL with Lewis Black" (deleted)

User image

Review of THE COMEDY-O-RAMA "SUMMER ROAD TRIP" SPECIAL with Lewis Black (deleted)

An incongruous melding of interview, standup and radio theater, this comedy special featuring Lewis Black easily cuts through the usual public radio monotone. The production values are excellent and it sounds much more like something from MTV or Comedy Central than, say, Fresh Air, TAL or Morning Edition. However, the narrative flow sometimes plays backseat to the rapid fire skits and I sometimes got a little lost in the piece.

This would make a good special for a holiday, or play very well next to other radio theater programs. The show doesn't identify itself well, so it could use an announcer or local host to break into the body of the special to let new listeners know what they're listening to.

Comment for "The Transom Radio Hour - Audio Diaries" (deleted)

User image

Review of The Transom Radio Hour - Audio Diaries (deleted)

If there was a radio hall of fame, both Jay Allison and Joe Richman would be founding inductees and it's a real pleasure to hear the two of them talk about their craft. Very rewarding. The features in this show are all excellent and extremely compelling.

However, though The Transom Radio Hour is intended to be a look into the craft of making radio, I wonder if some of the conversation is a little too "inside baseball" and whether listeners will be engaged or turned off. Could go either way. That said, as soon as the radio diaries start playing, I think anyone would be hard pressed to turn the station.

Comment for "Southwest Side Stories: Crazy Jimmy"

User image

Review of Southwest Side Stories: Crazy Jimmy

This is a short essay scored with music and sound effects about a local street character in this youth reporter's neighborhood. The story is short and would work well as a companion piece or coda to a longer feature about people living on the street, about loneliness or about death and loss. Jillian's writing is very descriptive and she does a good job painting a picture of what life must be like for Crazy Jimmy. Her read is good and the piece moves along at a fine clip.

However, after hearing this piece, I'm confused as to why the reporter didn't interview Jimmy himself. This is an essay full of speculation about a particular person when, in fact, the person is clearly available for comment. While listening, I kept expecting the reporter to go to tape and I was disappointed when the piece ended without even a clip from Crazy Jimmy.

That said, I think this piece would be hard pressed to stand on its own but would really shine when played in conjunction with a related feature.

Comment for "Becoming a Man"

User image

Review of Becoming a Man

This episode of Outright Radio consists of two pieces about gender difference. In the first, a person born as a woman explains how he has always personally identified as a man, and how he then became a man, socially. In the second, a woman who identifies sometimes as a man, sometimes as a woman talks about how gender fluctuates in her life and how she uses that fluctuation to make social and political points.

I find this topic very interesting, however, I was left a little disappointed by this show, which is basically two interviews with some narration. Gender is a such a hot topic and passions around it run so high, yet these people all speak very dispassionately about their own lives. I would have loved to hear some moments from these peoples every day experiences and the experiences of those around them. They talk a lot about controversial things, but I never heard the controversy itself.

On the other hand, perhaps for some this would be a plus. Rational conversation about controversial topics is few and far between these days.

All in all, I'm rating this a three because the subject is by its very nature an exciting and interesting one. However, I'm not sure this show would reach out, grab me and hold my interest.