Comments for Stories from the NYPD

Piece image

Produced by [redacted] [redacted]

Other pieces by jrudolph group

Summary: An audio history of the New York Police Department
 

User image

Review of Stories from the NYPD

This solid documentary tells the story of the NYPD via pithy narration, quality production and a rich romp through archive recordings. There's even some surprising audio of Fiorello La Guardia urging new recruits to deal with "tinhorns" by giving them a "sock in the jaw". And yes, even Serpico makes an appearance.
This program is, however, marred by the consistent use of very brief clips, masses of information and breakneck storytelling in which the listener, this listener at least, just gets bogged down in the narrative. There is so much jam packed in here that I just don't know who to care about. At a certain point, I just didn't know where I was being led, got lost and, consequently, my mind started drifting. WNYC has produced a sonic soup that is a little too well seasoned.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Stories from the NYPD

A very interesting and informative piece. Well put together and organized. A good combination of insight, music, and clips from tv shows from the particular era. I very much enjoyed listening to it.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Stories from the NYPD

Insightful, fair and brave journey through NYPD's history. A history not always pretty, but constantly changing, albeit voluntarily or legislated.
Perhaps more in New York City, but truly in all American cities, it's sometimes tough to be copped. But it's far tougher to be a cop.