We're working on a new version of PRX. Want a sneak peek?

All Comments

Comment on piece: NYC Taxi Medallions

User image

Review of NYC Taxi Medallions

In terms of production this piece is very polished and it has the sound quality of something you would hear on "All things Considered," "Morning Edition," or "Market Place," however, it does not share their sensibilities. This is a great subject but this piece leaves you wanting to know so much more about the taxicab industry: the hard-core economics of owning a cab, what exactly is a hack license? What's the history of the medallion? Where are they manufactured? It would also be nice to hear from more dirvers and a couple of passengers. To Joel Meyer's credit this piece piques your interest but it doesn't follow through and the lack of forward motion leaves the listener stuck in first gear.

Comment on piece: Carvings

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Carvings

There’s a level of pathos here that you don’t get all that often, on the radio or any other medium for that matter. Carvings is poetic, honest and full of a yearning that’s almost palpable. It doesn’t adhere to any kind of formula. The difficult sense of hope it contains does not feel tacked on or clichéd, but feels earned. You’re never alone when someone speaks to you like Mathew Cowley does.

Comment on piece: The "Laggy" Awards

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The "Laggy" Awards

Tongue in cheek, self-deprecating, and so very true. A little inspiration for the small business person who feels all alone in a big, bad world.

Comment on piece: :60: Peepers

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of :60: Peepers

Growing up in Toledo, Ohio, the local public station [WGTE] used a piece like this to fill the 30 seconds between their overnight national feed - Night Music, as I recall - and the beginning of Morning Edition at 6:00 am. Theirs was bird song from the local marshes and lake. It was a gentle and almost subliminal wake up when the alarm went off rather than the "Drive Time Report" which many stations use. NOt sure if WGTE still does this, but I wish my local station did.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Same Sex Marriage (deleted)

I travel a lot for work, and heard this on a Public Radio Station, and am glad to have the opportunity to hear this again & offer my review.

Why has no one delved into the historical aspect of marriage...bush keeps talking about the sanctity of marriage, claiming some religious origin of marriage. Marriage is a civil union, and can also be religious one. Looking at the root of bush's religious marriage, the man owned his wife, or wives, as chattel, the same way he owned his slaves. Marriage is older than religion, and the state has no place mandating a constitutional ammendment that is so utterly & completely contradictory to the constitution.

Comment on piece: My Father's Songs

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of My Father?s Songs

I found this piece to be inspiring,honest and contemplative. I would like to hear this on the radio as it reminds me how all tribes on our planet are conected and how important it is to remember your roots.

Comment on piece: My Bi-(Partisan) Boyfriend**

User image

Review of My Bi-(Partisan) Boyfriend**

This is a sharp piece. Crisp, witty writing that evokes a lot of imagery. The humor is smart and original (a rarity for political humor) and plays with stereotype without becoming stereotypical.

However, speaking of playing to type...the "our side" references mentioned by another reviewer are a bit troubling, because it could be exclusionary (but not to the point that someone would be offended or not enjoy the piece). It's hard to tell if the writer refers to "our side" as in "her and the listener" (assuming the listener is liberal--a dangerous assumption) or as in (the less troubling) "her and her friends." This is very easy to fix, either by changing the references to "my side" or offering some parameters for what "our side" means early in the piece.

The pacing is a bit fast, and the breathy delivery seems a little forced at times, which makes it feel less personal/conversational and more like a comedy performance. The music bed under the last minute isn't necessary and doesn't feel purposeful, but it isn't distracting or bothersome at all.

Almost any station can use this piece, especially between now and the fall election. It would be a fun and refreshing addition to what, inevitably, will be a long, nasty, and monotonous election season.

Comment on piece: W.T.O. Protesters Reflect on Cancun

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of W.T.O. Protesters Reflect on Cancun

This piece provides a behind the scenes look at the WTO protests in Mexico in September 2003, from the perspective of several US protesters; it uses the benefit of hindsight to reflect on the problems and successes associated with the protests and touches on the links made between the disparate groups endure.

This piece could provide some context for the upcoming G8 meeting in Georgia in early June, which is expected to be heavily protested by many anti-global trade groups, and puts a human face, or at least a human voice on the motivations of the protest movement.

Comment on piece: Naked Barbies and Deflated Basketballs: A look inside the world of collectors

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Naked Barbies and Deflated Basketballs: A look inside the world of collectors

I loved this piece!
As a collector of things myself, i always find stories like this a bit frightening... will i end up collecting discarded pieces of rope?
Great sound. The music worked very well, it allowed the age of the collectables and often times the collectors to come through.
nice ending... "the recycling of america" - indeed it is, thanks for a great piece. i would love to hear this on the air.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Torturing Terrorists (es#57) (deleted)

A plain-speaking and brief discussion of an ethical dilemma, in this case, the torturing of captured "terrorists". This piece might over-simplify things (if all ethical problems could be solved in 2 minutes the world would surely be a better place) but it does address important issues in a simple and easily understood fashion, and allows feedback through a website, and as such encourages a dialogue, a laudable and essential ingredient in developing an ethical life. If this is part of a series, which I believe it is, it could be aired as a regular spot during ME or ATC and make a good addition to those shows.

Comment on piece: Kitty Keeps On Singing

User image

Review of Kitty Keeps On Singing

This piece is a testament to the sheer will of the human spirit to overcome adversity and move ahead. Wonderful use of the family's recordings interwoven with Kitty's incredible story make this piece an easy "yes". Especially for mother's day. The writing is strong, the editing seamless. Great flow. This piece deserves airtime.

Comment on piece: The Ring and I: The Passion, The Myth, The Mania

Review of The Ring and I: The Passion, The Myth, The Mania

The ideas in the work (and this piece) are so many, and so varied, that they do that job for you. In perhaps in the strongest testament to Wagner's musical genius (or the piece's editing?), the ideas are held tightly together by the promise of the music itself, deftly interwoven through key musical passages. The disparate interviews (talking about Food, Jung, Zeppelin, Incest, Answering Machine Messages) and music work together to give a resounding, if impossible to summarize, answer to that nagging question radio listeners everywhere must ask about a piece: "so what?"

A fast overview of the Ring at the beginning might have been nice -- but probably also impossible. This thing is too big to digest in any less time. And the ending is exactly right. Well worth the hour.

Comment on piece: Naked Barbies and Deflated Basketballs: A look inside the world of collectors

User image

Review of Naked Barbies and Deflated Basketballs: A look inside the world of collectors

There are 2 kinds of collectors -- those who collect for condition (mint coins, toys in the original unopened package, vinyl records that have never been played) and those who love the energy of objects that have been thoroughly used. This piece is about the latter -- people who love the texture of wear and tear. The topic of collectors is always fresh because it is about passionate and quirky people who have created interesting identities for themselves. This would be great on the air.

Comment on piece: Yo-Yo Ma: In his own words

User image

Review of Yo-Yo Ma: In his own words

Yo-Yo Ma is possibly the most congenial human being on the planet and it shows on this episode of In Their Own Words. I would urge classical stations in particular to find the three and a half minutes in their otherwise relentless walls of music to drop this in.

Comment on piece: The Zildjian Cymbal Tester

User image

Review of The Zildjian Cymbal Tester

Who knew that a recording of someone performing quality control would be this much fun to listen to? This story deserves airtime.

Comment on piece: RN Documentary: The Music House

User image

Review of RN Documentary: The Music House

Lovely, respectful documentary, filled with great sound, interesting information, and vivid details. The producer does an excellent job of weaving the elements into an almost hypnotic portrait of the music house-building project. The Baka live in the dense rain forest and learn to navigate by sound, which makes them a perfect radio subject. Interviews with various Baka, the musicians who are funding the project, and the builder give a strong sense of place and culture. Great range of tape -- everything from the trip ferrying tin into the forest, to Baka voices merging with the birds – engages the ear in a variety of ways. About art, life, honoring ancient ways, and creating community across cultures. An excellent way to spend half an hour. Can be broadcast any season, but feels timely this spring moment as our ears brighten at the sounds of birdsong.

Comment on piece: File Sharing Vox Pop

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of File Sharing Vox Pop

A solid , if unexceptional bit of work. A bit more probing questions might have been nice. The interviewer could have played devils advocate, getting into some more of the ethical issues involved. One student justifies his file sharing with the old "everybodys' doing it" excuse. Do they condone looting? How do the students feel about some of the pay-to-download services?

Comment on piece: Confused About Tax Cuts

User image

Review of Confused About Tax Cuts

Though we’ve just passed tax-paying day, this will remain timely all the way up to president electing-day. It’s a fairly simplistic look at the pros and cons of tax cuts, but by gum, there are lots of folks who just don’t think about what we lose as a society when taxes are cut. Clear statements pro and con from people who spend their lives thinking about economic matters are bracketed by a plain old citizen’s point of view. At 3:38, a good drop-in for an ATC break, or ME.

Comment on piece: Profile of Cpl. Chris Kotch

User image

Review of Profile of Cpl. Chris Kotch

A brief, intense audio portrait of a moment in young Kotch's life that is almost cinematic in its precise imagery. While we don't know exactly what happened to him, or what the injury was, the sound of his voice tells you something bad happened. It is not a normal sound, this voice he has. To hear him describe his "million dollar wound," (a wound that sends you home) followed by his yearning to return to the war is haunting. His descriptions of his erratic behavior and of his mother's reactions, are powerful and succinct. Very well edited. Already been on ATC, but would work as drop-in on ME, or around any programming about the war, the soldiers, the losses incurred.

Comment on piece: Autumn's Story

User image

Review of Autumn's Story

Not much production, some background rumble and voices, kinda short and simple. But gosh darn it, this piece stays with you. There's something about a lone person talking intimately into a recorder telling the most personal and difficult story of their lives. Draws you in like no other high tech production can do. This is a successful first person story and I hope that Amy continues producing. It's not easy to be this emotionally engaging and she did a good job....Where to air it? A magazine show that deals in first person diary stuff definitely. Certainly a good piece for stations to air for young people and the parents who love them....Dmae