Comments by Alla Pekareva

Comment for "That's My Song: Aliens Exist"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of That's My Song: Aliens Exist

I think that this is a really good piece. Vaughnjareya's story is very interesting and engaging. I find myself wanting to ask him more questions and to have him tell me more about his experiences growing up.

The cuts that made it into the piece were very well chosen. I was listening in to when Irina was interviewing Vaughnjareya, and the whole interview was filled with amazing stories. I have to really compliment Irina for the cuts that she chose. It definitely couldn't have been easy. For example, I love the part when Vaughnjareya tells us about stealing a bottle of mascara and painting on a mustache. I can really imagine him standing there, nervous and excited. I think that this is exactly what interview cuts should be like: interesting, relevant, and concise. The cuts were also mixed very well into the song. Where the interview was cut off, where the song came back up - great!

It makes me sad that a lot of the reviewers didn't really understand the piece. It wasn't a piece about how much Vaughnjareya liked the song; it was the experiences, memories, and feelings that it brought up inside of him. I agree with the idea that this song is very much a celebration of his life, and being able to listen to this piece and share in his story makes me feel very special.

Comment for "Mi Abuela's Lottery Dreams"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Mi Abuela's Lottery Dreams

The narration of this piece is very beautiful. There is so much great description here. I feel like I can really see Alca's grandmother leaning out of that white rolling chair to better see and hear the lottery announcer on the TV. I like how she weaves her grandmother?s voice in and out of the piece, and how she deals with translating the woman's Spanish. I also think that the inclusion of the lottery announcer's voice and the sounds of the ball rolling add to the piece. The end is very personal and moving, and I'm glad that she chose not to put any other sound there.

Comment for "Happy Accident"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Happy Accident

I like how the piece opens not with the narrator describing how this ?accident? happened, but with a poem that a boy in his old high school wrote. I think it helps bring people in. Martin has an interesting story to tell. It?s amazing (and so lucky!) that his schedule had gotten lost. This happy accident let him go into horticulture and discover his passion. When he?s talking, his voice is often shaky, and at times it seems that he is reading from a piece of paper. Even when he expresses his feelings, it doesn?t seem sincere. Other than this small detail, I think that this piece is great.

Comment for "Fidalgo Bay Audio Postcard"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Fidalgo Bay Audio Postcard

This is a wonderful audio postcard! I can hear wind and splashes and water and people scattering oyster seed. It's amazing - it's as though I'm standing right by the water. The sounds are awesome here. The story about the importance of oysters is fascinating in itself, and I think that the short interviews with the volunteers are well chosen. I learned so much just by listening to them. This is a wonderful audio postcard! I felt that it ended a bit abruptly, but for a small glimpse into the world of replanting oysters in Fidalgo Bay, this postcard is great.

Comment for "Day Campers Learn Through Discovery"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Day Campers Learn Through Discovery

This is an interesting piece about a special day camp focused on raising ecological awareness. Exploration is the main theme here. Campers get to explore and learn more about their environment, and it sounds like they have lots of fun. I would love to hear more about this amazing camp idea, and how it came about. It's not every day that you hear about a camp that is so environment-focused. It would be great if we could hear from the campers or from their families - what motivates people to send their kids to this camp? What do the campers like about it? I think that this piece could be made into a really cool larger one.

Comment for "Profile of the Duwamish Clean-up"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Profile of the Duwamish Clean-up

I love how this piece starts off with these great little details and descriptions. It really places me there. The history between the Duwamish River and its people is fascinating. They aren?t officially a tribe, so they weren?t given rights to it. But the people living there have a deep connection and feel a great responsibility to the river. The Duwamish man that Claire interviews expresses this bond that he feels. I feel, however, that the music playing behind the interview is very distracting and makes the man a bit hard to understand at times. Overall, her piece is moving and informative. I didn?t know anything about this river before, so I am glad that I was able to hear this piece.

Comment for "Durham Love Yourself"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Durham Love Yourself

I like this piece! Adrian explores the history of the slogan, its rise to fame, and what other people think about it. The background of the Durham slogan is very interesting to hear and it is blended well with people's opinions about the phrase. Some think that it's cheese-y, others think that it's great. The tone of the piece is very playful and Adrian's clear, outgoing voice is easy to listen to. I especially like the rap at the end of the song. It is fun and quirky and definitely added to the overall feel of the piece.

Comment for "Abstinence Footsy"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Abstinence Footsy

Why f*ck when there's footsy? This new addition to the No Child Left Behind Act is brilliant and will, of course, prevent premarital sex. And if proficiency in this vital skill isn't attained in a certain school, that school will be torched. It's wonderful. This satirical piece is great, and it definitely made me smile. I like how the beginning of the piece is an introduction by George Bush and that we hear applause from the audience Margaret Spellings is addressing. I would love to hear this piece on the radio.

Comment for "A Prohibition"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of A Prohibition

This is an amazing piece dealing with identity and what it means to be black. The three stories are fascinating and skillfully interwoven. The poem that one of the students reads is very powerful, and I loved the use of repetition in it. I think that the background music is beautiful and haunting and complements the piece so well. Everything just works here. I feel so lucky to have come across this piece.

Comment for "Arranged Marriage"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Arranged Marriage

I liked listening to Swati's mother's experience of having an arranged marriage. The traditions and customs were especially interesting to hear. What I thought was really cool was that historically, most Indian arranged marriages were between children, so they had them play games to get them to know each other. And even though most of the marriages now are between two adults, the game-playing tradition has continued. I feel that Swati talked a bit too fast at some points and at others she sounded almost bored. Also, the ending of the piece was very abrupt, with her mother all of a sudden saying, "Okay, bye!" With a few cuts and changes, I think this can be a really great piece.

Comment for "Teens and Dieting"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Teens and Dieting

Jennol talks about a new craze in dieting: eating organic food. People actually approach employees in organic food stores seeking diet tips! I thought that this was very interesting. I knew that there was a trend towards healthier foods and more sustainable agriculture, but I had no idea that people ate those foods as part of this new diet. How weird! Another diet is the no-diet diet, which calls for people to accept themselves, to eat balanced meals, and to exercise. I really enjoyed listening to Jennol's piece. Her voice is steady and confident. There isn't any background music, but we do get to hear the noises of the organic food store she visited.

Comment for "Interracial Dating"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Interracial Dating

Kona talks about interracial relationships and how people view them. She lists some very interesting statistics about which ethnic groups are more likely to date people outside of their group. I guess I'm incredibly naive, but I didn't realize that there are so many people who actually wouldn't date a person who wasn't of their ethnicity. The good news is that more people are becoming more accepting of interracial relationships. As she quotes in her piece, the number of such marriages has quadrupled since 1970. Her piece isn't groundbreaking, but it's still nice to listen to. She talks about how for a long time her grandfather wouldn't talk to her because she's the child of an interracial couple and mentions that eventually he came around. It would have been interesting to hear him speak about how that happened and how he feels about interracial relationships now.

Comment for "Let's Talk About Sex"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Talk

Ah, parents talking to teens about sex - so awkward, so embarrassing, so funny. It's definitely something most of us can relate to. It was fun listening to people's recollections of being given "the Talk." Johanna picked some great clips. Some made me laugh, some actually made me cringe, but they all felt real. In the end of the piece, she talked to her own parents about sex. It felt very intimate, as if I was sitting right there with them. This is a great piece, and I hope people get a chance to listen to it.

Comment for " Sixty Second Season: Teenagers' Memories of Fall and Winter"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Sixty Second Season: Teenagers' Memories of Fall and Winter

I liked the mix of fall stories and that everyone had their own bit to add. It made me smile and remember my own memories of the fall. The sound clips of the rain were beautiful! I could listen to those for hours. It would be interesting if other clips could be gathered. For example, one person talked about coming across Native Americans chanting, so a sound clip of that could be helpful in really placing the listener in that scene. I liked how the end of the piece signaled an end to the fall by having the speaker simply list his winter clothing. That was nice and well done. This piece left me feeling happy and warm inside.

Comment for "N.K. Hurst Bean Media Montage"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of N.K. Hurst Bean Media Montage

This piece is an interesting montage of voices, ranging from news channel reporters to the owners of the company being forced to close and the people of the local community. I would love to hear more from the people being interviewed. I think that these snippets would make a great beginning to a larger piece. I haven't heard anything before this about the closing of the N.K. Hurst Bean Company, but I would certainly like to know more now!

Comment for "Anorexia Blogs"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Anorexia Blogs

Christopher's piece is very informative and I learned so much from it. I had no idea that pro-anorexia online communities were so popular or that they had so many active members. (Christopher says that a certain community boasts of having 250,000 active members). These places provide support for people with anorexia ? as in offering diet tips and pages of pictures of thin celebrities. But sometimes they can be an individual's only cry for help. I really liked that we got to hear the perspective of a pro-ana blogger, who doesn't necessarily believe that these sites are bad. They might be the only place where individuals with anorexia can find others who understand them. I hope that everyone gets a chance to listen to Christopher's piece, since anorexia and especially pro-anorexia blogs aren?t things that many people know a lot about.

Comment for "New Snack Food Rules"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of New Snack Food Rules

So many schools across the nation are trying to offer healthier food to students. Katie's piece is full of interesting bits of information, like how at one school that she talks about, only 70% of the snacks sold in its vending machines have to be considered healthy according to the program. I can't help wondering how well this will work. (30% of the food sold will remain fatty, sugary, and whatnot.) Still, it's great to hear about initiatives to give students healthier options. I only wish that Katie were able to get nicer cuts. There's often noise in the background, which takes away from the otherwise polished feeling of the piece. I also wonder how students at these schools reacted to the changes. It would have been nice to hear their perspective too.

Comment for "Marissa's Grandma"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Marissa's Grandma

This is such a great piece! Marissa?s voice is clear and confident, and you could tell that she really appreciates her relationship with her grandmother. I thought that their relationship was really cute. I loved hearing all the little details, like how her grandmother would rub her feet and how she taught her sayings in other languages. I?ve never met anyone who was so close with his or her grandmother. ?Marissa?s Grandmother? really celebrates family and gives you a warm, fuzzy feeling inside.

Comment for "Talk Early, Talk Often"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Real Truth about Teens and Sex

I think being open about sex is extremely important, and Aiofe and her mom both agree. It was really nice listening to them talking about, um, talking about sex. The piece was short and simple: it was just the two of them, no music, no distractions, nothing. They were calm and comforting, which I thought was great since this topic makes just about everyone nervous. (Seriously, how comfortable do you feel talking to your parent or your child about something as intimate and personal as sex?) They definitely made me feel more comfortable with the idea of bringing up sex with my parents. I felt that a lot of the time Aoife and her mom were speaking without any emotion or feeling, as if they were just reading from a piece of paper. At one point, it got almost ridiculous. After her mom spoke about the importance of being willing and ready to talk about sex, Aiofe said something like, "As a result, our relationship is very open and we both feel comfortable discussing whatever we need to, even sex." The way she said that line, it was as if she meant the exact opposite.

Comment for "Slip of the Tongue"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Slip of the Tongue

Slip of the Tongue speaks of ridiculous societal standards and how we lose ourselves when we get caught up with them. I love Adriel’s piece so much. It is beautifully written – the way he plays with words is magic. His performance is very passionate and full of emotion. I did not want it to end so I had my player loop this piece. (I even emailed the link to my friends.) It felt like a wakeup call. What sorts of things have I been prioritizing? Every time I listen to it, I pick up on something new. I hope that everyone has the opportunity to hear this piece and truly listen to what Adriel is saying.

Comment for "Just the Facts Please, OKthx"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Just the Facts Please, OKthx

So how well informed are Americans? Um, not very, and the choice of media might be to blame. *cough* Fox News Channel *cough* Chase is very opinionated and passionate, and I love his writing. It’s refreshing to hear someone express himself so freely. He’s not another one of your liberal friends ranting about why the Democrats lost the election. I love his sense of humor and the catchy beat sometimes playing in the background. The first two minutes of the piece are a bit unclear, though. He speaks too quickly and some of his words end up getting slurred together. But afterwards, it feels like Chase gets more confidence and energy and really comes out. I’d love to hear more of his pieces.

Comment for "East Coast Culture Shock"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of East Coast Culture Shock

Nora talks about her experience at “a small, traditional liberal arts college in the Northeast” that isn’t diverse at all. Her voice is clear and strong, and it’s obvious that she’s a great storyteller. I can see her college and dorm room with the pictures of her friends on the wall. I feel myself cringe as she describes students in her class using the word “Negro.” My reaction isn’t only to their behavior. Nora is very angry, but she doesn’t explain anything to them. I think that she is too quick to judge these people in her piece – maybe the students just didn’t know what they were doing or how they were affecting others. It’s also too easy for her to put down her school’s “monochromatic” student body and praise Berkeley’s diversity. I would like to see her go deeper into these issues.

Comment for "America- The Beautiful?"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of America- The Beautiful?

“If this had been an actual emergency, you would run, duct-tape your rooms up, and hide with your American flag.” This is such a great line, describing how many things now are often a frenzy of patriotism and fear. Ray Charles’s slow, beautiful song comes up and then the alert siren goes off over it several seconds later, followed by bombs. The irony works so well here. It reminds me of what Michael Moore did in Bowling for Columbine, where he combined footage of violent overthrows with languid music. It all starts to feel a bit prolonged and just when you’re wondering if the war will ever end, Ray Charles abruptly gets cut off by the nuclear blast. It’s powerful and intense and definitely disturbing. So click and listen.

Comment for "Jehovah's Witness"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Jehovah's Witness

Gabriela speaks slowly, almost as if she were hesitant about revealing her true feelings. She describes the change she saw in her mother after the woman had become a Jehovah’s Witness beautifully: “She no longer told me what she liked or believed in. She told me what the Bible said.” The piece is quiet and this makes Gabriela’s words hit us even harder. I wish she wouldn't bring up her brother in the piece and just focus on her and her mother. Her brother has an interesting story to tell, but I think his would work better as a separate piece. I love that we get to hear Gabriela’s mother speaking in the background. It's like I’m sitting just across from them. I was so caught up in her story that I was sad to hear it end.

Comment for "Youth Vote 2004"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Youth Vote 2004

The piece starts off with a t-shirt that says, “Voting is for old people.” It’s a funny message, but is it true? Antonia, the narrator, doesn’t believe it is. She interviews people from the Bush and Kerry campaigns about youth voters, and does a great job at integrating the interviews into her piece. Her cuts are wonderful. You hear everything you need to from the person, and the less concise stuff gets summarized. Her tone is playful but sometimes serious. She brings up a really interesting point: Politicians spend a lot of time visiting college campuses, but often ignore other youth populations, even though more than half of young voters aren’t even in college! She shows us through a cool collage of student voices that youth aren’t just concerned with malls and videogames. They care about the same issues as adults. This is a great piece to play before and during elections. It certainly reminds me how much I want to vote in the next ones.

Comment for "Elections for Dummies"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Elections for Dummies

Want to learn (almost) everything you need to know about elections in a minute and half? Then this is the piece for you. It’s easy to listen to Justin and understand what he’s talking about. The piece sounds like a presentation from my American Democracy class – but much more interesting. The length of it is perfect. I didn’t have time to zone out, like I would have in class. And you couldn’t, even if you wanted to, because the background noise/music keeps you alert. “Elections for Dummies” is perfect for youth to hear right before elections.

Comment for "Personals"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Personals

In “Personals,” Casey flips through a bunch of local personal ads, including one titled, “I make passes on women who wear glasses.” Listening to the voicemail ads was definitely entertaining, and I especially loved “Episcopalian Guy.” His tone was just so great. However, when I clicked to listen to the piece, I thought that I would soon be rolling on the floor laughing. But I just sat in front of my computer, not really feeling anything. The piece tries to be funny, but Casey sounds too detached for anything to happen. Come on and say something! The last thirty seconds felt a bit loose, and I wasn't sure where she was going. I think the piece would also benefit a lot from more upbeat and humorous background music.

Comment for "My Criminal Life"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of My Life as a Criminal

“My Life as a Criminal” pulls you in right away with its rawness. Mark is honest and the honesty hurts. He tells us everything, including his drug abuse, suicide attempt, and drug withdrawal. His mother doesn’t hide anything either. Her voice cracks with emotion as she remembers the past eight years of Mark being in and out of prison. I feel that Mark and his mother linger too much on the past; I’d like to hear more of what they have to say about the present and about Mark’s future. Dark, repeating music plays throughout the piece, which makes listeners feel trapped in this kind of life, just like Mark. The effect is chilling and powerful, but I feel like the piece is trying too hard sometimes. The slam of the prison gate isn’t necessary, and neither is the half-minute of additional angsty music at the end.

Comment for "The Graceful Art of Breaking Up"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Graceful Art of Breaking Up

Yay! It’s almost Valentine’s Day again, but instead of hearing the lovey-dovey side of it, the piece is about breaking up. Still, it’s light and cute – perfect for this holiday. I really liked the song playing in the background, and the mix of all the different responses was great. I wish I could hear more from these people. The narrator of the piece, however, sounded a little bored and even like she might have been reading off a paper. But maybe I’m just negative because Valentine’s Day is coming up and I don’t have someone to be with.

Comment for "And, How Does That Make You Feel?"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of And, How Does That Make You Feel?

“And How Does That Make You Feel?” is an amazing radio drama that takes us into Stella’s world when she attends her first therapy session with her mother. The characterization is right on. We have Stella, the typical depressed and suicidal teen, her upper-middle class “I know my daughter better than she knows herself” mother, and the therapist who asks the same frustrating question, “And how does that make you feel?” over and over again. The acting is great, but what really makes the radio drama work for me is the background music. It drives the piece forward and provides transitions from reality to Stella’s recurring fantasies of hurting herself. (I love the montage of voices that represent the crazed ones in her head.) Still, it is sometimes difficult to tell whether we are in Stella’s mind or in the therapist’s office. But then again, clear distinctions between fiction and reality are rare in a depressed mind. I could easily relate to Stella, and I’m sure most teens could too.