Comments by Holly Leopardi

Comment for "AP Slackers"

User image

Review of AP Slackers

Short and concise insiders guide to what happens to students after the AP test. It is something that any student who has ever taken an AP class knows, and usually expects after the tests are through. This would be an interesting piece to share with parents of AP students, as it might give them a little more insight into their students classes. The variety of interviews in this piece gives a spectrum of opinions and a more journalistic, news flash spin. The tempo of the piece is upbeat and extremely effective for a story of this kind.

Comment for "Ricky, The Banjo, and Me"

User image

Review of Surrounded by Music

I can still hear the sound seeping down through the floorboards, and the guitar playing in the background. This essay is light and personal and makes me wish I had music experiences like this. The narrators voice is extremely musical and the rich guitar gives the narration another dimension. Interesting techniques make the interview more raw and realistic, with transitions that seem as if it is being conducted live. While the guitar does contribute to the overall piece, at times it overpowers and takes away from the dialogue underneath. This piece sounds polished and other than the loud guitar, would a nice addition to a radio show.

Comment for "We Are Lane One"

User image

Review of We Are Lane One

Nothing makes a better radio commentary than a person?s most embarrassing moment. Not only does the writer have to relive their experience, but they are sharing it with whomever will listen. There is a certain quality of voice that can only be paired with this type of essay, a sort of strained painful one in that you can tell the reader is still as familiar with the way this incident made them feel as the moment that it happened. All this is present. The tone, the story constantly going down hill and the brutal honesty that is required to make the piece one of complete humiliation. This story was such an easy one to relate to and the writing sometimes veered off into very vivid descriptions that helped to push the story forward and help the listener gain more perspective into how the narrator was feeling and what they were noticing at the time. Some musical transitions or foley could contribute to the overall feeling, however it an effective commentary as is. The best part of this whole ordeal is that the swimmer never gets better or moves up out of lane one, and instead spends her time making up cheers and dances.

Comment for "Dear David"

User image

Review of Dear David

This is an excellent ?found radio? piece where a commentary develops out of something completely ridiculous and out of the ordinary. The pacing is so upbeat and the musical undertones effectively foreshadow what is to happen in an upcoming email, as well as the tone of the readers voices as they read adds another dimension to the piece and makes it almost visual. The writing is interesting in how it jumps around from different parts of the story without getting the listener confused. It would be nice to hear a little more of the narrator?s side of the story and background, but the ending thoughts are so comforting that the piece leaves a lasting impression.

Comment for "Islands Are Forever...An Interview With Islands"

User image

Review of Islands Are Forever...An Interview With Islands

Interviews are a huge part of radio. This piece just needs a little bit of editing and narration to help it be radio listenable. The questions created a great response from the band, however it was hard to decipher the audio at times. Perhaps a bio of the band and its members, and a little bit of their music being played underneath would morph it into more of a radio doc. I would really like to hear this piece completed, because the Islands are a very influential band and the interview was very dynamic. Right now the piece is just a little to raw.

Comment for "A student perspective on previously-loved clothing"

User image

Review of A student perspective on previously-loved clothing

Most kids I know shop at thrift stores mainly because they are a less expensive alternative as well as a more original one. The intro to this piece is very strong, with things that you knew about the clothing industry, with very specific details that you were less likely to know. The descriptions of the thrift store experience were ones that I could relate to and they turned ended up creating more of a story than a journalistic piece, which is a very interesting take on the matter. The music in the end was a very nice closing touch and it would be nice to have some more music or sound throughout the piece to help with its pace. A follow up story to this might be to document the different reactions of people when you tell them where different items of clothing were bought. Remember its not used clothing, its just ?pre-loved?.

Comment for "A Communicative Divide"

User image

Review of A Communicative Divide

The intro caught my attention and I was engaged for the rest of the piece. A huge variety of dynamic interviews helped me, a white American who has lived here all her life, understand what its like to feel excluded from your culture, and from your family. For many different reasons first generation Americans do not know their native language, and these youth are passionate about their homeland, but embarrassed about not knowing their culture. The part that was especially hard hitting was when the girls were talking about the embarrassment they feel because they cannot communicate with their family members in their homeland. Another thing that gave the piece more insight was the interviews were not one sided, and it goes on to explain the parents views of the issue. This piece is edited incredibly well and the narration keeps up a steady pace that helps push the concept across.

Comment for "Getting Raised 2"

User image

Review of Getting Raised 2

This is an interesting view of a teen that recognizes that having a family is not a bad thing. A good majority of teens wish they didn?t have a family and often act as if they don?t. It?s refreshing to hear a story that shifts the idea and speaks from experience about being raised in a very large family. This piece is heartfelt, although it could use a little editing to create a better flow, and perhaps some background music that would give some insight into Felix?s family traditions. Another intriguing part of this narrative is the part about what Felix?s grandmother has taught him about Hopi traditions and how growing up without his grandfather made him appreciate the family he has even more. It would be interesting to go more in depth with what his grandmother has taught him, and could perhaps develop into an entirely separate radio piece.

Comment for "Anywhere But Now"

User image

Review of Anywhere But Now

?Anywhere But Now? explains verbatim the way I feel. At one point Maria asks if everyone thinks about where they belong, and why they feel connections to places that they have no connection to, I know exactly what she is talking about. The music layered underneath the essay was completely amazing and the way it was edited took nothing away from the idea being presented, but greatly added to the mood as music in well edited radio pieces seem to have the tendency of doing. Maria?s reading voice is so warm, and its as though she has invited you into her comfortable living room, sat you down on the couch and is telling you a story that you are so compelled by you don?t interrupt. After the immediate story ends with her leaving the ?Past Life Regressionists? office feeling like a complete failure, she comes to some conclusions about how perhaps its our culture, perhaps its technology that takes away the feeling of knowing exactly where you belong because people have less time to reflect on where they really want to be and what they really want to be doing. The essay writing is top notch, the transitions in and out of various tape gives it a more on-the-spot feel, like you are witnessing something happen, and while listening, the majority of the notes I took consisted simply of the word amazing in all capital letters. My physical reaction to this piece was having goose bumps cover my entire body.

Comment for " The Story of a Nation"

User image

Review of The Story of a Nation

In Aysar?s interview with an 80-year-old survivor of the 1948 Naqba, the desire to go home is constantly looming. The man tells a brief story about his experience with being forced to leave, but he begins by saying this is not only a story of a single person?this is a story of an entire people, an entire generation has grown up in a refugee camp. The music layered throughout the piece sets the mood of longing to return home but overall this piece has little closure, although that could be because there is no closure in the refugees lives, their problems still exist. This piece has a very smooth flow, however it is hard to understand at some points because of all the layered sounds. It would be interesting to compare the stories of those who were evacuated with the stories of the people who had grown up in the camp, and hear more about their idea of home and where they belong.

Comment for "The Conversation with Shelby Knox"

User image

Review of The Conversation with Shelby Knox

It?s hard to talk about sex. Especially when you have only been taught that it is morally wrong to have until marriage and you have grown up in a society where having a dialogue about it is somewhat taboo. Shelby Knox, the subject of an independent film about what public schools sex education is really like, is someone who is not afraid to cause controversy. The interview between Knox and KRBC Voices of Youth producers is incredibly honest and comfortable. The questions asked provoke stunning replies from Knox, although the delivery on some of the questions is a little slow. Their questions imply having similar experiences as Knox in the area of public schools sex education, however, because this is just raw tape of the interview, it is only alluded to. Some narration with background information on Shelby Knox, as well as anecdotes about the interviewers? own experiences with sex ed in schools would help this piece be more listenable. Completed, this piece would contribute greatly to the sex education reform that is extremely important to the youth of today.

Comment for "Digital Diary: Kerrel McKay interviews other AIDS Activists in Toronto"

User image

Review of Digital Diary: Kerrel McKay interviews other AIDS Activists in Toronto

Kerrel reports from the 16th International AIDS Conference bringing up the interesting and pertinent topic of youth dealing with HIV and. She asks questions that arouse great response from her subjects about their views on how youth are dealing with AIDS, and the sound quality of this piece is incredible. Kerrel has awesome interviewing technique - and we gain great perspective with the information that is received from listening to this piece. A little more narration could be used for extra background on the topic and her interviewees, as some of their responses seem to come out of nowhere, and in some
places the listener has a hard time connecting them together. Kerrel?s ending narration in extremely powerful and positive as she concludes what steps the youth of the world must take in the fight against HIV and AIDS.