Comments by Taki Telonidis

Comment for "A Burden to be Well: Sisters and Brothers of the Mentally Ill"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of A Burden to be Well: Sisters and Brothers of the Mentally Ill

This deeply moving documentary reveals the hidden suffering of the sisters and brothers of the mentally ill. The range of distress experienced by these so-called ?well siblings? includes guilt for not being the one afflicted, resentment toward the ill sibling, and post traumatic stress disorder. Reporter Karen Brown threads together interviews with a wide variety of well siblings and experts to call attention to the stresses and burdens of being the ?normal? child in a household turned upside down by mental illness. The listener is taken to two such homes, where the relationship between the ill and the well sibling is exposed for all its complexity; stresses and resentments are openly discussed?as is the unique bond that these siblings have for each other. Powerful radio about a powerful subject.

Comment for "The Mashpee Wampanoag Indians of Cape Cod" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Mashpee Wampanoag Indians of Cape Cod (deleted)

This is a compelling story about the Native American people of Cape Cod?the Mashpee Wamponoag. In a relatively short time, reporter Sean Corcoran sums up the history of these people, explains the reasons for their present-day plight, and offers up reasons for optimism for their future. The strong narrative arc is held together by clear and succinct writing, well-chosen actualities, and scenes which add texture and give a sense of place. The history of the Mashpee Wamponoag is impressive. They?ve been on Cape Cod for 12,000 years & taught the Pilgrims to farm, but were eventually removed from their land. Some managed to stay, but the present-day pressures of real estate development and tourism have made Cape Cod unaffordable, forcing many of these Indians to live in the woods. This piece exposes a powerful drama which will play out over the next decades and which hopefully will receive more attention.

Comment for "Border Music - Grupo Fantasma" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Border Music - Grupo Fantasma (deleted)

This music piece is fun, informative, and lively. Reporter John Morthland chooses Laredo, Texas to explore music of the US/Mexico border, and he does so with musician Adrian Gonzalo from Grupo Fantasma. Fantasma?s particular mix is flavored by various influences from the musicians? youth near the border, and is further seasoned by an emerging appreciation for the music of their parents. There?s a nice pacing between actuality and music, and an engaging, relaxed delivery by reporter and interviewee. The conversation strikes a nice balance between personal history, and ethnomusicology. This piece is a refreshing antidote to all the political talk these days about the US/Mexico border.

Comment for "Global Warming: Oceans" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of OPEN SOURCE: Global Warming: Oceans (deleted)

This interview focuses on a subset of the global warming issue which was unfamiliar to me: the warming of the oceans. And it?s not just temperatures that are affected by the waters? absorption of enormous amounts of carbon dioxide; the ocean chemistry is changing, and organisms at the bottom of the food chain are disappearing. While the topic makes me stop and listen, this piece does not always hold my attention as a piece of radio. The interviewee is a scientist from the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, and while he's very knowledgeable about the topic, he does not have an engaging manner of speaking. The interviewer Christopher Lyden tries to infuse energy into the conversation, but with only partial success. Some questions work while others are not as focused and succinct as they could have been. I appreciate that this piece brings an important topic to my attention, and hope it?s explored further through sound-rich feature stories as well as through interviews.

Comment for "NPR's All Songs Considered: The Music of Portugal"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of NPR's All Songs Considered: The Music of Portugal

I learned a lot from this musical journey through Portugal. The tour guide is Portuguese DJ Alvaro Costa, who is interviewed by NPR?s Bob Boilen. Costa speaks with passion and energy, briskly taking the conversation from romantic music through jazz, then on to music that?s influenced by African and pop beats. Musical examples of each type of music punctuate the discussion. While both the talk and the music are interesting, the piece falls into a predictable pattern; it would have been nice to mix it up a bit. Boilen does a good job of pointing the conversation in interesting directions, but there are a couple of moments when he and Costa talk over each other, competing to make a point. All in all though, this was a fun piece that makes me want to hear more music from Portugal.

Comment for "Johnny Cash: Amazing Grace"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Johnny Cash: Amazing Grace

This feature is an exploration of the influence of Christian faith on the life and music of Johnny Cash. The story is told chronologically, beginning with his mother?s love of gospel music, and how faith helped Cash heal after the loss of his older brother, then how religion saved Cash from the demons of drug abuse. Friends, fellow musicians, and even Cash?s son John Carter Cash give first-hand accounts from the country legend?s life. Reporter Rodney Crowell has a nice delivery and builds a nice overall narrative, although there are spots in the piece that lose momentum. It?s refreshing to hear songs in their entirety instead of in 30-second fade-ups, but there are a few songs in the middle of the piece that are similar to each other. While Cash?s repertoire of gospel songs might not be what he?s best known for, this piece helps me understand what made him tick, as a musician and as a human being.

Comment for "It's A Nice Day for A Green Wedding"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of It's A Nice Day for A Green Wedding

Here it is?in less than 90 seconds?everything you could possibly want to know about planning a wedding that will produce a minimum of garbage and carbon emissions, while putting money in the coffers of environmentally friendly non-profit organizations, and still keeping your guests entertained. While a wedding like this may not be everyone?s cup of tea, it?s fun radio. Nice, crisp writing and brisk delivery?with the occasional tongue-in-cheek line. When so many weddings are memorable for all the wrong reasons, why not plan one that?ll be memorable for all the right reasons.

Comment for "The Art of Family"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Art of Family

This is a heartwarming story about a middle-aged man with Down Syndrome, his 94-year old mother, and their abiding love for each other. Doris Joyce?s love for her son gave him the confidence and skills to build a career as an artist and contribute to the family, while John?s love for his mother is helping her meet the challenges of failing health. The piece is finely crafted by reporter Colleen Iudice who weaves powerful actualities with understated writing. There are a few bumps in the narration, and the sound mix could have been a bit smoother, but this a powerful story with a lesson for all of us.

Comment for "Resurrecting the Zapara"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Resurrecting the Zapara

This is a compelling documentary about the struggle for cultural survival of a tiny indigenous tribe in the Amazon known as the Zapara. In just 14 minutes, this piece weaves seamlessly between Zapara history, explanations of their present plight, and sound-rich scenes of contemporary village life. It?s an inspiring story of a people making a conscious decision to regain control of their destiny after being dominated by outsiders for more than a century. It?s an effective piece of radio with strong scenes, well-recorded sound, and descriptive narration. I did find some of the voiceover translations a bit flat, but this was offset by strong content.

Comment for "Gov. Schwarzenegger Headlines Environmental Conference at Georgetown University"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Gov. Schwarzenegger Headlines Environmental Conference at Georgetown University

I was initially doubtful that a speech about global warming would make for good radio, but I was pleasantly surprised. Governor Schwarzenegger did everything a good radio producer should do. He was informative yet entertaining; his story had a strong narrative, and his delivery was relaxed. He began by drawing parallels between body building and the environmental movement, then explained his view that America has reached the ?tipping point? regarding the environment. He sprinkled the speech with examples of effective environmental policy, as well as personal anecdotes about why this has become such a big priority for him. Schwarzenegger spoke for about 20 minutes, then took questions for another 20. His speech was preceded by several minutes of introductions and ?thank you?s? which didn?t really work on radio. But his speech, or excerpts from it, are worth considering for broadcast.

Comment for "Mysterious Disappearing Bees"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Mysterious Disappearing Bees

This competent reporter piece gives an overview of the crisis that bee populations are experiencing across the US. The story begins with a nice piece of sound, and includes a few other examples of good audio. The narration is straightforward and clear, although it could have been read with more energy. Actualities include bee farmers, apple growers and scientists who explain the various aspects of the collapse of bee colonies. They provide good information, although I would have wanted to learn a bit more about the beekeepers? craft, and to hear more about the impact the collapse is having on them on a personal level.

Comment for "Generation Next: Child vs Adult"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Generation Next: Child vs Adult

Delightful. That?s the first word that comes to mind after hearing this installment of a BBC series about adolescence. Initially I was doubtful that a 20-minute radio story would be able to bring focus to such a broad topic, but I was pleasantly surprised throughout this piece. It unfolds in a very logical manner, beginning with an engaging introduction, then a series of topics illuminated by the personal experiences of teens (as well as of the reporter, now an adult) plus a sprinkling of experts. The narration is cleverly written and delivered with sparkle and humor. He relates very well to the young people he interviews, and in the course of the story takes us all over the world?from the UK, to Zambia, to America, to India & Bangladesh. Music and sound are used effectively to create a sense of place and pacing. This piece prompts me to ask questions of myself, and to appreciate how much Westerners could learn from other cultures, particularly traditional cultures, who seem to do a better job of preparing their children for adulthood. I could go on, but best to listen for yourself.

Comment for "Jaron's Story of Coming Out"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Jaron's Story of Coming Out

Perhaps the thing I like most about Jaron?s story is how his personality comes through between the lines of his monologue. His positive outlook and compassion allowed him to be forgiving of his parents? reactions when he first told them he was gay, even though he was going through a difficult period himself. To other gay teens experiencing the emotional pain of coming out, he advises that they study the history of gay people in America and take strength from the strides made by those who preceded them. The honesty of his voice translates into eloquence even though Jaron?s writing is inconsistent at times. There are also places where the music drowns what he?s saying; I couldn?t make out several passages even after hearing them three times. This is a piece worth considering even though it isn?t as polished as it might have been.

Comment for "Jean-Yves Thibaudet in Concert"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Jean-Yves Thibaudet in Concert

Listening to this piece is a pleasant way to spend an hour. It features pianist Jean-Yves Thibaudet performing selections by composers Robert Schumann and Maurice Ravel from Disney Concert Hall in Los Angeles. The live recording has that ?take you there? quality although I could strangle the man in the audience with the cough. The performances are broken up with commentary by Renee Montagne and actualities of Thibaudet explaining his interpretations. It?s just enough information to give those who know little about classical music (like me) an appreciation of what the composer and performer are trying to achieve with their music.

Comment for "A Letter Sound Memories" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of A Letter Sound Memories (deleted)

Sound has the ability to trigger memories from the past, giving us the opportunity to relive dramatic and poignant experiences. A perfectly fine premise for a radio story, yet one that isn?t fully realized in this instance. Though the reporter provides lots of description about the discovery of an old cassette tape and the experience of hearing it for the first time in years, I never reached a level of empathy that would have allowed me to share in her enthusiasm. I might have felt a stronger connection if the audio were a bit more unique. The strongest section of the piece is a description of a visit to the pyramids in Egypt where the reporter visited the tomb of an ancient queen. It was here that I was able to feel some sense of the power of the moment, and found myself wishing the rest of the story could have resonated in a similar way.

Comment for "What's the Word? Pride and Prejudice"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of What's the Word? Pride and Prejudice

This is an appreciation of Jane Austin?s novel ?Pride and Prejudice? and the reasons this romantic comedy remains popular nearly 200 years after it was written. With help from three Austin experts, the host explores the economics of 19th century marriage, the various modern adaptations of Austin?s story, and what the novel reveals about the status of women in Regency England. Although much of the information conveyed in the piece is interesting, a less formal approach would have made for more engaging radio. The host?s narration is quite formal as are the comments by the experts, all of whom are professors; at times it feels as if I'm attending a lecture. One of the most effective elements is the generous use of period music which does succeed in transporting me back in time and conjuring images of aristocrats exchanging glances and banter, as they waltz to a string quartet.

Comment for "Uses of Fear" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Uses of Fear (deleted)

This is one of those rare pieces that I wanted to just keep on going. First of all the topic?fear?is something we can all relate to. More importantly, the execution is intelligent and creative. This story is comprised of three judiciously-edited conversations with people whose lives have been dictated by fear in one way or the other. The most compelling is a convicted murderer who describes how he used fear as a tool in his life of crime. Each person gives a different perspective on fear and how it?s affected their behavior and mental state. The reporter Ben Adair is present sparingly, asking only the occasional question to keep the conversation moving. Music is also used minimally, but to great effect. In short this is powerful radio that will make listeners ponder fear in their own lives.

Comment for "Buzz, Bands and the Biz: Why SXSW Matters"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Buzz, Bands and the Biz: Why SXSW Matters

This piece plots the South by Southwest (SXSW) festival on the world atlas of the music biz. It begins with a brief history of the ascendancy of Austin Texas as a music hub, and the genesis of this festival as an enticement for the bi-coastal music industry to take notice of the unique sounds of Austin. It then muses about how the festival has been changed by its own success, and its struggle to find balance between big-name performers and up-and-coming acts. Though there?s quite a bit of music and actuality, this is more of a business piece. The music is used to dress up the story, but doesn?t propel the narrative as it might have. Some of the actualities have that ?take me behind the scenes? quality while others lack that immediacy. The tempo of the piece starts off quick and is quite textured with songs and actualities, but it loses momentum about halfway through. Two songs are played in their entirety, and the piece ends with a rather long interview. What I like the most about this piece is that it does pull back the curtain on the music industry?explaining the importance of creating a buzz, showing the exhilaration of discovering a hot new performer, and conveying the frustrations of musicians who despite their best efforts never catch the ear of the career-makers. Individual passages of this feature are quite strong, yet as a whole it doesn?t quite sing.

Comment for "Wayfinders: A Pacific Odyssey"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Wayfinders: A Pacific Odyssey

This is a competently produced report about the rebirth of Wayfinding, an ancient form of marine navigation used by Pacific Islanders. The story is largely drawn from a film documentary about Wayfinding which chronicles the voyages of Hokulea, a traditional canoe that has been navigated great distances with this technique. The story?s structure is straightforward and the narration clear. The piece touches on several interesting themes such as how Wayfinding has instilled a sense of pride and dignity to the Hawaiian and other Pacific cultures. The topic is worthy of a more expansive report, one that might include scenes from an actual voyage, and which looks more deeply into how the rebirth of Wayfinding is changing the lives of the people who are practicing it for the first time in generations.

Comment for "Edge of the Rez, Hour One"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Edge of the Rez, Hour One

Edge of the Rez examines the border towns where Native American culture intersects with white culture. The show is a collection of several features that address issues such as discrimination, the role of family, the effects of relocation, alcohol abuse, and the importance of traditional culture in overcoming these and other problems. Each story is well done, and a couple are exceptional. Music is used effectively both to transition between pieces, and to further the narrative within individual stories. The hour-long show works as a whole, but several segments could stand on their own or work as a series. This is an important and poignant body of work because it points out both the harsh reality as well as the beauty that can be found on the edge of the rez.

Comment for "Stephen Buhner - The Secret Teachings of Plants"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Stephen Buhner - The Secret Teachings of Plants

This is an interview with author Stephen Buhner about the cognitive powers of the human heart, and it?s ability to perceive things that the brain cannot. While this should make for fascinating radio, several factors in this piece make it less satisfying than it could be. The interview is conducted over a poor phone line which at times makes it difficult to understand what Buhner is saying. This is a discussion about big and complex concepts, and every word counts. And because the topic is so cerebral, I found myself wishing that the interviewer had focused the discussion on one or two major points in the book, rather than trying to cover as much ground as she does. An occasional challenging question would have made the discussion more dramatic and lively. Despite these issues, Buhner comes through as a compelling thinker, and I find myself wanting to learn more about the concept of direct perception.

Comment for "RN Documentary: The Music of Love (Valentine's Day special)"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of RN Documentary: The Music of Love (Valentine's Day special)

This is a sobering antidote to the saccharine sentiments and plump roses that bloom on greeting cards around Valentine?s Day. The piece is set at the piano of Gary Goldschneider where he?s interviewed by reporter Dheera Sujan about the influence of love and passion on classical music. Though the piece gets off to a slow start (it takes more than 3 minutes before we hear music) it succeeds in drawing connections between some of the most romantic music ever written, and the love lives of Tchaikovsky, Mahler, Beethoven, Schumann and other great composers. Goldschneider has an intimate understanding of the tormented personal lives of these people, and points out passages in their music where their suffering finds expression. Unrequited love, homosexuality, love triangles?it?s all there. The production is straight forward (interview mixed with music), and the audio recording of the piano could have been richer. Yet after a few minutes I found myself immersed in melody and story, soaking in the emotions that flow through this music.

Comment for "RN Documentary: Taming the Salt Monster"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of RN Documentary: Taming the Salt Monster

This is a well put together documentary that chronicles the transformation of Western Australia?s bush country into farmland, and the grim ecological aftereffects of this change. The reporter pulls together a variety of compelling voices to build a narrative that explains what?s at stake because of this practice. There are compelling first-hand accounts of how thousands of acres of vegetation were burned each day in the 1950?s and ?60?s, and how animals were desperate to escape the blazes. The science behind the degradation of the soil is explained thoroughly, although there are a couple of terms that aren?t defined. The story also touches on the anguish felt by today?s farmers who consider themselves stewards of the land, yet whose heritage is tainted by the destructive practices of their ancestors. All in all, this is a story worthy of considering for broadcast, particularly given the current national discussion about environmental issues.

Comment for "Radio from the Bering Sea"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Radio from the Bering Sea

This story competently encapsulates the sad history of this remote corner of the United States, where native peoples were exploited by Russian fur traders for hundreds of years, and displaced in the last century by the US government. The piece then profiles a pioneering radio station, and its efforts to rebuild this community of Aleut people now spread out over a wide geographic area. Through music and storytelling, the piece conveys the flavor of native culture in addition to touching on the harsh realities of life for these people. The production is solid, though the narration is bit stiff and at times difficult to follow. Despite these shortcomings, this piece is a worthy reminder of the power of radio to serve rural communities.

Comment for "Sa Pa" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Sa Pa (deleted)

At the beginning, this soundscape drew me in and made me close my eyes in an effort to visualize the journey to a Hmong Village. By the end, however, I wasn?t quite sure where I?d been or what I?d heard. I appreciate the effort to allow the sound to speak for itself, and the reporter did a nice job in his recording and mixing. But many of the sounds were not unique enough to generate a vivid experience. Even a bit of context in the introduction would have allowed my imagination to riff on what I was hearing and paint a picture. While this effort may not have been entirely successful, I do hope the reporter will continue to experiment with this type of storytelling.

Comment for "Dear Skinwalker"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Dear Skinwalker

From the first note of music, to the haunting quote at the end, ?Dear Skinwalker? is a magnificent piece of radio. This story is so different, that it?s difficult to describe. As the summary states, it?s a letter from a young Native American woman locked up in a detention center written to a spirit creature called Skinwalker. She talks about her troubles, fantasizes about the future, regrets her past, and muses on the wisdom a long-dead Indian chief. The writing is superb, at moments real and gritty, at others surreal and impressionistic. The story flows like a stream of consciousness--a collage of thoughts, sounds, and music that takes unforeseen turns, yet holds together for the most part; only once during a digression about a high school debate club did I feel lost. To experience this piece is to feel like you?ve penetrated the subconscious of this young woman, seen her dreams, and felt her anguish. Congratulations to KRCB and Voice of Youth.

Comment for "An Interconnected Christmas"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of An Interconnected Christmas

This one-hour special is a collection of 9 conversations about the meaning of Christmas?all set to music. The perspectives are for the most part non-traditional and include authors, pastors, mystics, a specialist in rituals, and an aroma therapist. Some of the discussions are quite esoteric, and at times difficult to follow. Others are insightful, and include interesting history and analysis. The hosts engage well with their guests, but their questions from guest to guest are often repetitive, as are the answers. Although I can?t say the show held my attention for the entire hour, it did make me slow down, and contemplate the meaning of the holiday for myself. This self examination was a welcome retreat from the frenzy of the holiday season.

Comment for "RN Documentary: Pagans and Patriarchs"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of RN Documentary: Pagans and Patriarchs

This documentary succeeds in transporting me to the other side of the world, and into the vast forests of Russia where ancient pagan rites are being performed for the first time in centuries. The reporter builds scenes with sound, music, and actualities spoken in unfamiliar and exotic languages. The rituals are examined from within?with voices of participants and religious leaders, and from the outside?by folklorists and historians. The reporter?s narration is straightforward and informational, and it does get overly ?ethnographic? at times. He attends three different rites, and sets each of them up in a similar fashion; for variety it would have been nice to try a different approach with each example. The return of these pagan rites is controversial, and the reporter handles the controversy well?although fairly late in the piece. Despite this, and the occasional uninspired voice-over translation, this piece is an enjoyable and worthwhile journey.

Comment for "Indian Gaming"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Indian Gaming

This is a straight-forward summary of the affect that gaming has had on Indian reservations in Oklahoma. Its structure is in the NPR style of a brief scene at the top followed by acts and trax that highlight the pro?s and con?s of the issue at hand. The reporter?s writing and delivery are competent and easy to follow, and the story provides pertinent facts and figures. What the story lacks however is an emotional, or human element. Gaming has obviously had an enormous impact on the daily life of Native people in Oklahoma, yet I don?t get much of sense of this in this piece. By relying heavily on experts, I found myself wanting to hear the voices of everyday people whose lives have been changed for better, or for worse by this phenomenon.

Comment for "Sanapia's Courage Medicine"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Sanapia's Courage Medicine

This interview between reporter Tanya Ott and poet & actress Laura Secord (from The Vagina Monologues) tells the story of a Comanche medicine woman whose life was the inspiration for a new cycle of poems. Secord eloquently describes how Mary Poafybitty?s story touched a cord with her at a sensitive time in her life, and how Comanche attitudes regarding women and aging are a refreshing change from Western ways of thinking. The medicine woman?s personal story is compelling, as is her affect on Secord?s life. My only quibble with the piece is the format. Rather than as an interview between reporter and guest, I think it would be easier for stations to use were it packaged as a reporter piece, or edited into a monologue by Secord.