Comments by Josh Gleason

Comment for "Legal Status"

User image

Review of Legal Status

This piece has received a fair amount of attention - and for good reason. This is a great piece of radio. An honest, personal account that cuts through the immigration bluster in a affecting, intimate way. Vera's situation is more complex than the black and white debate the immigration issue is often reduced to. And this nuance makes it an engaging and valuable listen.

There's a certain amount of bravery at work here - Vera has the guts to capture some very tense arguments with family members over how she should best approach her legal limbo. And she doesn't shy away from asking pointed questions.

The only thing I find lacking is a more definitive ending - the piece winds down quickly, and ultimately strikes a whimsical note that kind of threw me.

But overall I think PDs would be hard pressed not to find a reason to put this on the air - particularly if they're looking to cover immigration in a compelling, refreshing way.

Comment for "Deported: Weazel's Diary"

User image

Review of Deported: Weazel's Diary

I'm almost at a loss for words. This is a stunning human-scale portrait of the actual implications of US immigration policies. Being a little ADD I was initially intimidated by the length - but this piece is totally engaging the whole way through. The scenes are woven together effortlessly and build upon one another to a truly powerful ending. Now if we could only create an army of Joe Richman clones and send them out to make an endless stream of fabulous radio documentaries. I'm thinking a whole Joe Richman frequency. Maybe satellite channel?

Anyhow, given the current immigration debate in this country there is no excuse to not air this - it doesn't perfectly map onto the issues at hand - but it brings home what it means to strand family members on opposite sides of the border.

Comment for "Fashion Obsession"

User image

Review of Fashion Obsession

Pretty much everything that radio rookies does is excellent. But this piece in particular got my attention because the producer, Shakima, is a radio natural. Her narration is playful and engaging - a joy to listen to. This is a fun, light-hearted, personal investigation of the economic toll of clothing addiction and the social pressure to keep up appearances. I could hear it working in a feature-y show or towards the bottom of a news program. Great for Fashion Week.

Comment for "Kasper Hauser: Phone Call to the 14th Century"

User image

Review of Kasper Hauser: Phone Call to the 14th Century

I rarely laugh out loud at comedy on the radio. I often find it more embarrasing than it is humorous. But this piece got me giggling. Great concept, well written, with some very nice performances...it shows how good comedy on the radio can be.

Comment for "Joey's Phone Call Home"

User image

Review of Joey's Phone Call Home

I've been in love with Joey ever since I heard his "Pee in the Pudding" piece on This American Life. This recorded phone call is not all that remarkable in terms of content: there's no drama, no punchline/gut-wrenching moment. It's just a kid calling his mom from jail. That's why it's great. I think it would make a nice addition to a show about incraceration, or perhaps about the telephone.

Comment for "Who's Your Daddy?"

User image

Review of Who's Your Daddy?

This is an interesting story about a woman's semi-whimsical interest in obtaining sperm from a masseuse she meets on a trip to Hawaii. The only problem is that the piece is too This American Life-esque. Don't get me wrong, I'm a big fan of the program, but their style is so defined that anything that sounds like it feels derivative. This piece even employs songs that are regularly used on TAL (for better or worse TAL owns the Yo La Tango track "Green Arrow" - I don't think anyone can really use it at this point). Nevertheless, it's a good narrative and there's great reflective tape.

Comment for "Harry Nilsson and the Case for Profanity"

User image

Review of Harry Nilsson and the Case for Profanity

A sort of interesting idea for a piece about censorship (at least an instance that I wasn't familiar with) except that I feel like I didn't learn much about the actual case and the grounds on which it was decided, or any reprecussions that it might have had. And if the piece is fundamentally about a couple guys going to jail for playing a Nilsson song why do we only hear some archival tape of Nilsson but no tape from the guys who actually went to jail from playing the record? It seems to me like telling the story from their perspective would have made it much stronger.

Comment for "My Lobotomy"

User image

Review of My Lobotomy

The most chilling radio story I have ever heard. Infact, the first time I heard it I felt physically ill. This is an incredibly brave and important story that should be required listening for all. I believe this already aired nationally on Morning Edition or All Things Considered but if you're a station that doesn't pick up those shows I think you should consider investing in this as a weekend special. Who knew how rampant lobotomy was as a practice? Not I.