Series: The Depreciating American Dream

Produced by Curt Nickisch

Series image
Image by: Jess Bidgood, Andrew Phelps 

Owning a home has long loomed large in the American story; the notion that buying a house is the stepping stone to wealth and happiness goes back a long time. But the housing bubble has burst, and many homeowners are living in the shadow of the white picket fence. How has the collapse forced us to rethink owning, renting and alternatives?

Does everyone really need to own their own home? Until the recent housing market crash and the great recession, hardly anyone questioned the value of homeownership. It cured poverty, crime... everything but cancer.

But that infatuation with the white picket fence is ending. Thanks to the swift rise and calamitous fall of the housing market. Homes have become, in all too many cases, a huge financial liability. The opposite of what people signed up for.

The fact is, renting has real advantages over owning. It’s really not true that “you’re just throwing your money away.” You have more mobility in a modern economy. And renting may even be the better investment.

Through a series of personal case studies of homeowners and renters, WBUR's Business Reporter Curt Nickisch takes a hard look at the popular conceptions concerning housing, and the new calculus facing people today as they decide how - and in what sort of home - they want to live. Hide full description

Does everyone really need to own their own home? Until the recent housing market crash and the great recession, hardly anyone questioned the value of homeownership. It cured poverty, crime... everything but cancer. But that infatuation with the white picket fence is ending. Thanks to the swift rise and calamitous fall of the housing market. Homes have become, in all too many cases, a huge financial liability. The opposite of what people signed up for. The fact is, renting has real advantages over owning. It’s really not true that “you’re just throwing your money away.” You have more mobility in a modern economy. And renting may even be the better investment. Through a series of personal case studies of homeowners and renters, WBUR's Business Reporter Curt Nickisch takes a... Show full description


4 Pieces

Order by: Newest First | Oldest First
Caption: Steve Meacham in his limited equity co-op apartment in Cambridge, Mass., Credit: Curt Nickisch
We've heard from people relieved to be renting. We've heard from homeowners struggling to make it work. Could there another way? In the wake of ...

Bought by Remix Radio


  • Added: Apr 02, 2010
  • Length: 00:04:06
  • Purchases: 1
Caption: Meenal Bagla (left) and Prashant Jeloka ran the numbers, and decided renting was the superior financial - and lifestyle - option compared to buying., Credit: Jess Bidgood
Two couples from Boston's Brighton neighborhood -- one young, one old -- have had the money to buy a home but choose to keep renting. In the third ...

Bought by Remix Radio


  • Added: Apr 02, 2010
  • Length: 00:05:39
  • Purchases: 1
Caption: Andrea Quenneville used to spend weekends camping, but homeownership means raking and mowing have become the new outdoor family activities., Credit: Jess Bidgood
Andrea and Raymond Quenneville think they timed it about as well as they could, taking the plunge last year at what they considered a low point in ...

Bought by New Hampshire Public Radio and Remix Radio


  • Added: Apr 02, 2010
  • Length: 00:04:23
  • Purchases: 2
Caption: One on summer day, Calvin Sangster saw two people arguing outside his house in Mattapan. “Once had the guy on the ground he pulled out the gun and started shooting him with it,” Sangster said. That’s when he said it was time to move out., Credit: Jess Bidgood
The Sangsters of Boston's Mattapan neighborhood thought they were doing the right thing for their young family. But just about everything that coul...

Bought by Remix Radio


  • Added: Apr 02, 2010
  • Length: 00:06:38
  • Purchases: 1