Caption: "The great Bartholdi statue, Liberty enlightening the world", Currier & Ives, 1885, Credit: Library of Congress
Image by: Library of Congress 
"The great Bartholdi statue, Liberty enlightening the world", Currier & Ives, 1885 

City Upon a Hill: American Exceptionalism

From: BackStory with the American History Guys
Series: BackStory with the American History Guys: Full Episodes
Length: 54:00

Embed_button
This week on BackStory, the History Guys tackle the myth of the city upon a hill: American exceptionalism. They trace its origins in Alexis de Tocqueville and follow it through to the 2012 presidential election. Read the full description.

Bartholdi_enlightening-213x300_small

Almost two centuries after Alexis de Tocqueville said that the U.S. was an exceptional case in the history of democratic societies, the idea of “American Exceptionalism” is alive and well. Almost every GOP candidate for president in 2012 has invoked the notion, each suggesting that President Obama doesn’t sufficiently embrace it. And so you might be surprised that, 90 years ago, American communists were Exceptionalism’s biggest fans.

From the Puritan vision of a "city upon a hill" to the 19th century concept of manifest destiny, from Woodrow Wilson’s vision of the U.S. as a worldwide model to Ronald Reagan’s invocation of the Puritans, this episode looks at the changing meanings of Exceptionalism, exploring what has influences Americans' perceptions of their difference - the sense that they have a special place in the world.

Also in the BackStory with the American History Guys: Full Episodes series

Caption: Charles Peale’s Mastodon skeleton, by Édouard de Montulé (1816)

The Departed: Extinction in America (54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

Some 20,000 species across the globe are at high risk of extinction, experts say – many here in the United States – and some of our natural fauna have already disappeared. So ...
Caption: Strikers from the Ladies Tailors Union, 1910 , Credit: Library of Congress

Fair Wages: A History of Getting Paid (54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

In his 2014 State of the Union address, President Obama called on Congress to increase the federal minimum wage to $10.10. And last month, he signed an executive order ...
Caption: Player for the Chicago Kent College of Law indoor baseball team, 1910, Credit: Library of Congress

Turf War: A History of College Sports [2014] (54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

As the nation plunges into March Madness 2014, betting on who will make it to the Final Four and claim college basketball’s championship, BackStory aims for some historical ...
Caption: Shades of Green, Credit: Wikimedia Commons

The Green Show (54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

With St. Patrick’s Day on the horizon, the color green seems to be everywhere we look. So BackStory sets out to celebrate the holiday with an offbeat, wide-ranging, and ...
Caption: Shades of Green, Credit: Wikimedia Commons

PROMO - The Green Show (:30)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

30-second promo for BackStory episode, "The Green Show," with 5-second music bed at end for station-specific time/date tag.
Caption: The Pantages Theater in Los Angeles, decked out for the 1959 Academy Awards, Credit: UCLA Library

Real to Reel: The 2014 Oscars Show (54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

In honor of the Academy Awards, BackStory heads to the movies! With Oscar-nominated movies like "12 Years A Slave" bringing the antebellum United States to the fore, and ...
Caption: “The Almightier,” illustration from Puck, May 15th, 1907 , Credit: Library of Congress

On the Money: A History of American Currency (54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

There’s a lot of talk about Bitcoin these days—the digital currency that's been gaining ground. Bitcoin allows online payments to be made person-to-person, instead of via a ...
Caption: Detail from Chicago Department of Health vaccination poster, produced by the Works Progress Administration, late 1930s , Credit: Library of Congress

Contagion: Responding to Infectious Disease [rebroadcast] (54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

It’s the height of the flu season, and federal public health agencies have been spending millions of dollars trying to keep this year’s virus under control. But when yellow ...
Caption: "Sugar - save it!" Detail from U.S. Food Administration poster, c1917 , Credit: U.S. National Archives

Sweet Talk: A History of Sugar (54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

Valentine’s Day is around the corner, and that means candy, chocolate, cakes – all the sweet stuff for your sweetheart! It’s just one of the ways sugar has seeped into our ...
Caption: Affectionate Valentine couple, c1890., Credit: Wikimedia Commons

Outed: Sexual Identity in America (54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

As the Winter Olympics in Sochi approach, countries around the world have expressed concerns over Russian legislation outlawing LGBTQ “propaganda.” The Obama administration ...

Piece Description

Almost two centuries after Alexis de Tocqueville said that the U.S. was an exceptional case in the history of democratic societies, the idea of “American Exceptionalism” is alive and well. Almost every GOP candidate for president in 2012 has invoked the notion, each suggesting that President Obama doesn’t sufficiently embrace it. And so you might be surprised that, 90 years ago, American communists were Exceptionalism’s biggest fans.

From the Puritan vision of a "city upon a hill" to the 19th century concept of manifest destiny, from Woodrow Wilson’s vision of the U.S. as a worldwide model to Ronald Reagan’s invocation of the Puritans, this episode looks at the changing meanings of Exceptionalism, exploring what has influences Americans' perceptions of their difference - the sense that they have a special place in the world.

Timing and Cues

SENDER: VFH RADIO – CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA
RE: "BACKSTORY" RUNDOWN –AMERICAN EXCEPTIONALISM”
SHOW: BACKSTORY WITH THE AMERICAN HISTORY GUYS
HOSTS: BRIAN BALOGH, PETER ONUF, ED AYERS
TIME: 59:00

PRSS SHOW TITLE: BACKSTORYAMERICANEXCEPTIONALISM
BROADCAST WINDOW: 7/12/12-9/27/12

***********************************************************************

SHOW RUNDOWN

06:00 – 19:00 SEG A
IC: Major support for BackStory is provided by the National Endowment for the Humanities.
OC: You’re listening to BackStory. And we’ll be back in a minute.

6:00 - 8:53 Running Themes
The History Guys take a look at how the 2012 presidential candidates have claimed American Exceptionalism as a campaign mantra.

8:54 – 15:37 Tracing It Back
Peter, Ed, and Brian riff on what Exceptionalism has meant through the centuries.

15:38-19:00 Invisible Cities
Peter talks with historian Mark Peterson about John Winthrop’s oft-misunderstood sermon, “A Modell [sic] of Christian Charity,” in which the phrase “a city upon a hill” was first used to describe the New World.

19:00 – 20:00 STATION BREAK 1 (MUSIC BED)

20:00 – 39:00 SEG B
IC: We’re back with BackStory…
OC: We’ll be back in a minute.

20:00 – 26:53 Invisible Cities Continued
Peter continues his conversation with historian Mark Peterson about John Winthrop’s oft-misunderstood sermon, “A Modell [sic] of Christian Charity.”
26:54 – 31:51 Seeing Red
and share a little-known story about that time Stalin coined the term “American Exceptionalism.”

32:52 – 39:00 Who or Where?
Brian chats with Paul Kramer about a late nineteenth century debate: Was America exceptional, or were Americans exceptional because they descended from England?

39:00 – 40:00 STATION BREAK 2 (MUSIC BED)

40:00 – 59:00 SEG C
IC: Welcome back to BackStory with the American History Guys…
OC: …at the Virginia Foundation for the Humanities

40:00 – 51:28 Listener Questions
The History Guys answer questions from listeners.

51:29 – 57:35 For Purple Mountain Tragedy?
Brian talks with Katherine Meizel about the song “America the Beautiful” and its unsung verses.

57:42 – 59:00 PRODUCTION/FUNDING CREDITS

***********************************************************************
Contact: Producer, Tony Field (434) 924-8922, tfield@virginia.edu

Additional Credits

Virginia Foundation for the Humanities, National Endowment for the Humanities, The History Channel

Related Website

www.backstoryradio.org