
Civil War 150th: Why They Fought
Series: The Civil War, 150 Years Later
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
Length: 00:54:00
150 years ago this April, the Union went to war with the Confederacy. Ever since, Americans have been debating the causes of that war. Most historians today agree that it was fundamentally about slavery. And so what are we to make of the fact that most Southerners didn’t own any slaves, and most Northerners were not abolitionists?
In this hour of BackStory, historian-hosts Brian Balogh, Peter Onuf, and Ed Ayers turn the question of the Civil War’s causes on its side, asking instead why Northerners and Southerners took up arms to fight one another. What causes, in other words, were they willing to die for? By focusing on the lived experience of ordinary Americans, the episode will explore such questions as: Were families on the homefront united in their commitment to war, or were there differences of opinion? Who didn’t want to fight? What did slavery mean to white people on both sides, and what role did enslaved and free African-Americans play in the liberation of slaves? How much did Americans’ reasons for fighting change between 1861 and 1864? And finally – how have intervening wars altered the ways we interpret the motivations of Civil War soldiers?
Special guests for the hour include:
- Adam Goodheart (lead author, New York Times “Disunion” series)
- Christy Coleman (president, American Civil War Center at Historic Tredegar)
- Gary Gallagher (historian, University of Virginia)
- Aaron Sheehan-Dean (historian, University of North Florida)
More from BackStory with the American History Guys
Civil War 150th: Questions Remain
(00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
In this third part of BackStory's "Civil War 150th" series, the History Guys host a special listener Q&A. Over the course of the hour, they answer a wide range of questions ...
Civil War 150th: The Road to War
(00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
To mark the sesquicentennial of the Civil War's beginnings, the History Guys take an in-depth look at the pivotal six months between Abraham Lincoln's election and the ...
Monumental Disagreements: Memorials in America
(00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
In this Memorial Day episode of BackStory, we take on national remembrance. By looking at some of our country’s most iconic monuments, we ask what—and whom—Americans choose ...
PROMO - Monumental Disagreements
(00:00:30)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
Promo for stations airing the episode "Monumental Disagreements."
PROMO - Home Bittersweet Home
(00:00:31)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
Promo for stations airing "Home Bittersweet Home"
PROMO - Born in the USA
(00:00:30)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
Promo for stations airing the BackStory episode "Born in the USA"
Home Bittersweet Home: A History of Homeownership
(00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
In 1931, Herbert Hoover called the idea of owning one’s own “a sentiment deep in the heart of our race and of American life.” In this episode of BackStory, the Guys take on ...
Born in the USA: A History of Birth
(00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
The American History Guys are back! In this premiere episode of BackStory's new weekly schedule, we explore the history of childbirth in America. Topics include everything ...
Justice on Horseback
(00:04:34)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
Before "The People's Court," there was the circuit riding system. Supreme Court Justices traveled all over the country delivering--as one Senator put it--"law to the people's ...
Piece Description
150 years ago this April, the Union went to war with the Confederacy. Ever since, Americans have been debating the causes of that war. Most historians today agree that it was fundamentally about slavery. And so what are we to make of the fact that most Southerners didn’t own any slaves, and most Northerners were not abolitionists?
In this hour of BackStory, historian-hosts Brian Balogh, Peter Onuf, and Ed Ayers turn the question of the Civil War’s causes on its side, asking instead why Northerners and Southerners took up arms to fight one another. What causes, in other words, were they willing to die for? By focusing on the lived experience of ordinary Americans, the episode will explore such questions as: Were families on the homefront united in their commitment to war, or were there differences of opinion? Who didn’t want to fight? What did slavery mean to white people on both sides, and what role did enslaved and free African-Americans play in the liberation of slaves? How much did Americans’ reasons for fighting change between 1861 and 1864? And finally – how have intervening wars altered the ways we interpret the motivations of Civil War soldiers?
Special guests for the hour include:
- Adam Goodheart (lead author, New York Times “Disunion” series)
- Christy Coleman (president, American Civil War Center at Historic Tredegar)
- Gary Gallagher (historian, University of Virginia)
- Aaron Sheehan-Dean (historian, University of North Florida)
Timing and Cues
SHOW RUNDOWN
00:00 – 00:59 BILLBOARD
IC: From VFH Radio in Charlottesville, Virginia, this is Backstory.
OC: First, this news.
01:00 – 05:59 NEWS HOLE
06:00 – 18:59 SEG A
IC: Major Production Support for
OC: We’ll be back in a minute.
6:00-9:38 Intro / The Civil War Today
The History Guys introduce the hour’s theme and hear from Christy Coleman, the president of the American Civil War Center in Richmond, Virginia.
9:38-18:59 The Citizen Soldier in the Civil War
The History Guys consider the remarkable levels of volunteerism in the Civil War and discuss the power of the “citizen soldier” idea throughout American history.
19:00 – 19:59 STATION BREAK 1 (MUSIC BED)
20:00 – 38:59 SEG B
IC: This is BackStory, the show that brings three centuries…
OC: We’ll be back in a minute.
20:00 – 22:37 Which Side Are You On?
Historian and New York Times Civil War blogger Adam Goodheart talks about one of his favorite Civil War Letters.
22:37 – 33:39 Fighting for Union
Historian Gary Gallagher argues that the idea of “union” was what initially compelled most white soldiers in the North to join the army.
33:39 – 38:59 Fighting for Liberation
The History Guys discuss the important moral and tactical contributions of African-American soldiers in the Union Army.
39:00 – 39:59 STATION BREAK 2 (MUSIC BED)
40:00 – 59:00 SEG C
IC: This is BackStory, the show that…
OC: …VFH Radio at the Virginia Foundation for the Humanities.
40:00 – 51:29 Fighting for Home
Historian Aaron Sheehan-Dean explains how the idea of “home” motivated Confederate soldiers and strengthened their resolve to fight.
51:29 – 57:39 The View From Home/Conclusions
Historian Catherine Clinton discusses gender dynamics on the home front, and the History Guys consider some of the ways in which the Civil War is not like other American wars.
57:39 – 59:00 PRODUCTION/FUNDING CREDITS


