Piece image

Seeking Civility in Political Discourse (53:00)

From: Good Radio Shows, Inc.
Length: 00:52:55

Embed_button
A journalist and two political scientists talk about the often uncivil tone of political discourse, throughout history and in recent years. (Recorded in 2004 - this conversation has been edited to make it evergreen and new continuity added noting recent events, the shooting of a U.S. Congresswoman in Arizona) Read the full description.

Politics_medium_small If you applied for any job, would you publicly discredit the other candidates for the position in hopes of getting it yourself? Why is this technique practiced and accepted in running for political office in the United States, including in the race for the presidency? Why is political discourse in the United States so contentious and conflict-ridden, in general? Has it always been this way? Are we stuck with it or can citizens press for change? Host Suzanne Kryder talks with a panel to explore these questions. Guests include former Albuquerque Tribune managing editor Kate Nelson, Dr. Gilbert St. Clair, a lecturer in political science at the University of New Mexico and Dr. Guy Burgess, co-director of the Conflict Research Consortium at the University of Colorado. The show is complimented by interviews with citizens and samples of political ads from the last 50 years. Part One focuses on the tone of political discourse throughout history and why political speech between politicians today is so contentious. Part Two spotlights campaign advertising, the role of the media in setting the tone, and initiatives underway in some places to improve the tone. -0- NOTE FOR PROGRAM DIRECTORS: This program was originally produced in 2004 but has been edited to create an evergreen program that is still timely especially in light of the January 2011 shooting of  U.S. Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords.  This program will be expecially good for stations who don't have access to another conversation program about the recent news.

More from Good Radio Shows, Inc.

Piece image

The Peace Symbol's Story (Peace Talks Radio) [29:00] (00:29:02)
From: Good Radio Shows, Inc.

The origins of the ubiquitous Peace Symbol are revealed in conversation with author Ken Kolsbun. Also the proliferation of the symbol on clothing and accessories is explored ...
Piece image

Creating Community Cohesion by Improving Food Security (Peace Talks Radio) [29:00] (00:29:01)
From: Good Radio Shows, Inc.

Some social scientists see a link between food insecurity and a lack of peace in the neighborhoods known as "food deserts" or "food wastelands". Some experimental programs ...
Caption: People's Grocery Mobile Market in Action in West Oakland, CA, Credit: oaklandseen.com

Creating Community Cohesion by Improving Food Security (Peace Talks Radio) [59:00 / 54:00] (00:59:00)
From: Good Radio Shows, Inc.

Some social scientists see a link between food insecurity and a lack of peace in the neighborhoods known as "food deserts" or "food wastelands". Some experimental programs ...
Caption: Muhammed Yunnus

Peace Talks Radio: Reducing Poverty, Promoting Peace (29:00) (00:29:08)
From: Good Radio Shows, Inc.

This episode of Peace Talks Radio explores how micro-credit and other programs work to eliminate poverty and promote peace.
Piece image

Veterans Turning Towards Peace (Peace Talks Radio) [29:00] (00:29:02)
From: Good Radio Shows, Inc.

Conversations with two U.S. Military Veterans who have chosen different paths for peaceful action in the years following their military service. Featured are Gulf War Vet ...
Caption: Erik Gustafson, EPIC (lower right), Nabil Musa, Nature Iraq, (on computer) and Iraqi Youth Hike participants viewing wildlife photos from a camera trap near Mount Peramagroon, northwest of the city of Sulaimani, Iraq. , Credit: EPIC

Veterans Turning Towards Peace (Peace Talks Radio) [59:00 / 54:00] (00:59:03)
From: Good Radio Shows, Inc.

Conversations with two U.S. Military Veterans who have chosen different paths for peaceful action in the years following their military service. Featured are Gulf War Vet ...
Piece image

Seeking Peace Around Death and Dying (Peace Talks Radio) [59:00 / 54:00] (00:59:00)
From: Good Radio Shows, Inc.

Three hospice professionals explore ways for the dying and the survivors to find more peace around the death passage. This compelling hour also includes host Paul Ingles ...
Caption: James O'Dea

Becoming a Peace Ambassador (Peace Talks Radio) [29:00] (00:29:01)
From: Good Radio Shows, Inc.

On this edition of Peace Talks Radio, we explore an online training opportunity called Becoming a Peace Ambassador. James O’Dea, the facilitator of the Peace Ambassador ...
Caption: James O'Dea

Becoming a Peace Ambassador (Peace Talks Radio) [59:00/54:00] (00:59:00)
From: Good Radio Shows, Inc.

On this edition of Peace Talks Radio, we explore an online training opportunity called Becoming a Peace Ambassador. James O’Dea, the facilitator of the Peace Ambassador ...
Piece image

Peace on the Battlefield: The Christmas Truce of 1914 and Manassas Peace Jubilee (Peace Talks Rad... (00:29:01)
From: Good Radio Shows, Inc.

Two instances when peace broke out – right on the field of battle. First, the impromptu but widespread unofficial Christmas Truce of 1914 in the early months of fighting in ...

Piece Description

If you applied for any job, would you publicly discredit the other candidates for the position in hopes of getting it yourself? Why is this technique practiced and accepted in running for political office in the United States, including in the race for the presidency? Why is political discourse in the United States so contentious and conflict-ridden, in general? Has it always been this way? Are we stuck with it or can citizens press for change? Host Suzanne Kryder talks with a panel to explore these questions. Guests include former Albuquerque Tribune managing editor Kate Nelson, Dr. Gilbert St. Clair, a lecturer in political science at the University of New Mexico and Dr. Guy Burgess, co-director of the Conflict Research Consortium at the University of Colorado. The show is complimented by interviews with citizens and samples of political ads from the last 50 years. Part One focuses on the tone of political discourse throughout history and why political speech between politicians today is so contentious. Part Two spotlights campaign advertising, the role of the media in setting the tone, and initiatives underway in some places to improve the tone. -0- NOTE FOR PROGRAM DIRECTORS: This program was originally produced in 2004 but has been edited to create an evergreen program that is still timely especially in light of the January 2011 shooting of  U.S. Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords.  This program will be expecially good for stations who don't have access to another conversation program about the recent news.

Broadcast History

Recorded in 2004. Edited for timely rebroadcast in 2008 and 2011.

Transcript

PART ONE

SUZANNE KRYDER: Let me ask each of you, in a minute or less, to start out by giving us a quick assessment of what you feel the tone of our political discourse in America is today. Now, that's between politicians or even among citizens. Kate, we'll start with you.

KATE NELSON: It's different, depending on who's doing the talking. I think, among politicians, it's pretty hot. It's not the hottest it's ever been. It certainly could be a lot better, a lot more focussed on issues that matter. Among the electorate, I think there are two things going on. There's a sort of a moderate muddle in the middle, which is, in fact, a majority of people, who are taking politics pretty seriously or are somewhat apathetic about them, but aren't speaking about them in incivil terms. And then, there's the anger at the edges: the people who are listening to that hot-toned punditry and mimicing i...
Read the full transcript

Timing and Cues

FOR NON-NEWSCAST STATIONS

NO BILLBOARD
00:00:00 - 00:17:06 - Part A - ends with :60 music bed for local anncts.
00:17:07 - 00:37:14 - Part B - ends with :50 music bed for local anncts.
00:37:15 - 00:52:57 - Part C - ends with Bob Dylan's "Political World" which fades out.

FOR NEWSCAST STATIONS
NO BILLBOARD
00:01:00 - 00:05:59 - Your Newscast
00:06:00 - 00:23:06 - Part A - ends with :60 music bed for local anncts.
00:23:07 - 00:43:14 - Part B - ends with :50 music bed for local anncts.
00:43:15 - 00:58:57 - Part C - ends with Bob Dylan's "Political World" which fades out.

Intro and Outro

INTRO:

We are about to present a re-broadcast of a panel discussion recorded in 2004 featuring then journalist Kate Nelson, and professors Guy Burgess of the University of Colorado and Gil St. Clair of the University of New Mexico… all with host Suzanne Kryder exploring the search for civility in political discourse. We’re presenting this discussion again in light of the recent shooting of Arizona Representative Gabrielle Giffords and 17 others at one of the congresswoman’s public events Saturday January 8.

OUTRO:

Related Website

http://www.goodradioshows.org/peaceTalksL19-20.html