Caption: Artist rendering of the California High Speed Rail, Credit: CAHSRA
Image by: CAHSRA 
Artist rendering of the California High Speed Rail 

The Planning Problem

From: Nathanael Johnson
Length: 00:26:38

The Big Dig, the Bay Bridge, the Chunnel... Why do transportation projects go so spectacularly over budget? There's a simple explanation - this documentary uses California's experiment with high speed rail as a lens to see this problem with new clarity. Read the full description.

Picture_1_small The Big Dig, the Bay Bridge, the Chunnel...
Why do transportation projects go so spectacularly over budget? There's a simple explanation - this documentary uses California's experiment with high speed rail as a lens to see this problem with new clarity.

To hear the full audio, sign up for a free PRX account or log in.

More from Nathanael Johnson

Piece image

Overtreatment: How health care makes us sick (00:08:58)
From: Nathanael Johnson

The health-care debate is focused on quantity: how many people – and how much care they will get. But perhaps quality, rather than quantity of care, is more important.
Piece image

Classical Revolution (00:05:19)
From: Nathanael Johnson

Young classical mucisians jamming in bars are drawing young audiences
Piece image

Messiaen at 100: Apparition of the Eternal Church (00:06:08)
From: Nathanael Johnson

Messiaen did something to make just about everyone angry - so why are there people left who love him?
Piece image

Speculations: Real Estate meets String Theory (00:05:38)
From: Nathanael Johnson

The conceptual art of Jonathan Keats
Piece image

Literature and Music: Circular inspiration (00:05:31)
From: Nathanael Johnson

Books inspire musicians - music inspires authors.
Piece image

Polar Bears: Branding Global Warming (00:07:04)
From: Nathanael Johnson

Bear as symbol vs. bear in person
Piece image

Under the skin at the Museum of Verterbrate Zoology (00:11:44)
From: Nathanael Johnson

An stroll through the gory depths of a UC Berkeley Museum preparation lab -- the place where animals are skinned and stuffed for posterity -- in this audio report. [Warning: ...
Piece image

Recruiting Musician Soldiers (00:04:50)
From: Nathanael Johnson

The Army is using craigslist to recruit musicians.
Caption: PRX default Piece image

Redeveloping Oakland (00:16:06)
From: Nathanael Johnson

A history of redevelopment in Oakland, California.
Caption: PRX default Piece image

Web animation: a new genre of family entertainment (00:06:06)
From: Nathanael Johnson

Web animators whose art lands in the intersection of cute and ironic are drawing unbelievable numbers of fans.

Piece Description

The Big Dig, the Bay Bridge, the Chunnel...
Why do transportation projects go so spectacularly over budget? There's a simple explanation - this documentary uses California's experiment with high speed rail as a lens to see this problem with new clarity.

Broadcast History

First aired on KALW's Crosscurrents

Transcript

SHOW

NATHANAEL JOHNSON: All over the country, regional planners are working on high speed rail networks. President Barack Obama has said this is the time to build a modern passenger train system:

OBAMA: Building a new system of high-speed rail in America will be faster, cheaper and easier than building more freeways or adding to an already overburdened aviation system –- and everybody stands to benefit.

NJ: But this is also a time when Americans have little faith in their government’s ability to build big: After Boston’s Big Dig – the tunneling project that went five billion dollars overbudget, and California’s Bay Bridge replacement – which is expected to cost taxpayers seven billion dollars more than estimated – the people of this country are legitimately skeptical.

California is first in line to build high speed rail. The whole system will cost somewhere between 42 and 45 billion...
Read the full transcript

Timing and Cues

Room in the half hour for host intro and NPR headlines. Can edit in a break for station identification in the interview in the middle.

Intro and Outro

INTRO:

(perhaps tie in local building projects that have gone over budget - or with breaking news - the following is merely suggestion, don't have to name the station or me in the intro or outro)
If you've been paying attention you can probable name a some government building project that has taken far longer than expected, while costing more money. We now bring you a documentary that seeks to explain why these projects seem to go so routinely over budget. From the NPR affiliate KALW in San Francisco, Nathanael Johnson has this report: The Planning Problem.

OUTRO:

That was "The Planning Problem" from KALW in San Francisco.

Additional Credits

Additional engineering: Chris Hoff

Related Website

http://kalwnews.org/audio/2010/07/21/planning-problem-documentary-high-speed-rail_482014.html