Caption: PRX default Piece image
PRX default Piece image 

Hanukkah: A Great Miracle Happened There

From: The Radio Foundation, Inc.
Length: 00:58:49

A conversation between Rabbi Ismar Schorsch and Host Larry Josephson about the history, rituals and meaning of Hanukkah--and its importance in our time. Read the full description.
${title}
To hear the full audio, sign up for a free PRX account or log in.

More from The Radio Foundation, Inc.

Piece image

ONLY IN AMERICA: Program 1. The First Jews (00:58:57)
From: The Radio Foundation, Inc.

Their long climb from poverty to prominence and prosperity in the New World
Piece image

ONLY IN AMERICA: Program 2. The Streets Were Paved with Gold: A Journey Through The Jewish Lower ... (00:58:57)
From: The Radio Foundation, Inc.

Jewish immigrants found a harsh life and no gold on the Lower East Side. The program describes aspects of daily immigrant life including tenements, sweatshops, unions and ...
Piece image

ONLY IN AMERICA: Program 3. Becoming Americans: A Journey Through the Jewish Lower East Side of N... (00:58:58)
From: The Radio Foundation, Inc.

The Yiddish Theater - Culture and religion of the Old Country abandoned - The Triangle Shirtwaist fire - Assimilation into mainstream America
Piece image

ONLY IN AMERICA: Program 4. White Christmas: The Story of the Jews Who Created Tin Pan Alley & Ho... (00:58:58)
From: The Radio Foundation, Inc.

Jewish immigrants like Irving Berlin, Harold Arlen and George Gershwin reinvented American popular music
Piece image

ONLY IN AMERICA: Program 5. Over the Rainbow: The Story of the Jews Who Created Tin Pan Alley and... (00:58:52)
From: The Radio Foundation, Inc.

Yiddish-speaking moguls like Louis B. Mayer and Samuel Goldwyn created Hollywood, and an idealized, small-town Protestant America that never was.
Piece image

ONLY IN AMERICA: Program 6. No Dogs or Jews Allowed: The Story of Antisemitism in America. (00:58:54)
From: The Radio Foundation, Inc.

The Story of Antisemitism in America - Father Coughlin, Henry Ford and Charles Lindbergh publicly denounce Jews - Joe Lieberman chosen to run for Vice-President
Piece image

Bob & Ray THE LOST EPISODES "PROMOS" (00:03:43)
From: The Radio Foundation, Inc.

Additional promos for use with the 13 one-hour program series.
Piece image

Bob & Ray THE LOST EPISODES Program 1 (00:58:57)
From: The Radio Foundation, Inc.

Part 1 in a series of 13 one-hour programs featuring the most beloved characters and sketches from comedians Bob Elliot and Ray Goulding.
Piece image

Bob & Ray THE LOST EPISODES Program 2 (00:58:28)
From: The Radio Foundation, Inc.

Part 2 in a series of 13 one-hour programs featuring the most beloved characters and sketches from comedians Bob Elliot and Ray Goulding.
Piece image

Bob & Ray THE LOST EPISODES Program 3 (00:58:45)
From: The Radio Foundation, Inc.

Part 3 in a series of 13 one-hour programs featuring the most beloved characters and sketches from comedians Bob Elliot and Ray Goulding.

Piece Description

"A Great Miracle Happened There: A Hanukkah Special," is a conversation between Rabbi Ismar Schorsch and Host Larry Josephson about the history, rituals and meaning of Hanukkah--and its importance in our time. Cantors David Lefkowitz and Elisheva Dienstfrey sing the music of Hanukkah. Rabbi Ismar Schorsch explains that Hanukkah is really about a Jewish civil war, a war between assimilated, Hellenized Jews and a pious band of zealots, the Maccabees. The well-known "miracle of the oil," occurs at the end of the story--after the Temple has been retaken by the Maccabees, and rededicated and cleansed. Rabbi Schorsch also talks about Hanukkah as "the Jewish Christmas." Dr. Ismar Schorsch is Chancellor of the Jewish Theological Seminary in New York. Larry Josephson is a veteran public radio host and interviewer, whose programs have been heard in New York, and nationwide for over 35 years. Glorious music of Hanukkah is sung by Cantor David Lefkowitz of The Park Avenue Synagogue in New York, and by Cantor Elisheva Dienstfrey, now of Congregation Agudas Achim in Alexandria, Virginia. Both are graduates of the Seminary. Additional music from "Voice of the Turtle" and the Zamir Chorale of Boston.

2 Comments Atom Feed

User image

Review of Hanukkah: A Great Miracle Happened There

Everything You Always Wanted to Know About..Hanukkah. I'm one of those that doesn't know much, except the old saw about it being a minor holiday to compete with Christmas, which turns out to be somewhat true. Larry's guide and guest, Rabbi Ismar Schorsch, chancellor and history chair of the Jewish seminary in New York, is knowledgeable and articulate - and stick around for the moving personal Hanukkah story he modestly slips in. I'm not a Jew (except I'm a New Yorker which gives me a certain claim!)- but with the loud, simplified, all pervasive Christian clamor I'm hearing on all levels and from all corners coming from my native country I found this program a welcome, soothing and important listen.

User image

Review of Hanukkah: A Great Miracle Happened There

Making religious programming is always a tricky business. The program maker must always ask him or herself the questions, "For whom am I making this: the converted or for the general public?" "Will this be an entertaining secular exploration or a sober religious exaltation or a bit of both?"

This program seems to have chosen for a hybrid which, frankly, doesn't work. Two clearly erudite men, one a rabbi, ploddingly discussing the fine points of history and Talmud as plaintive Semitic hymns pop in and out behind them. The idea is to distill the modern and religious significance of the Jewish Festival of Lights over the unfortunate length of an entire hour. I say unfortunate because the format of such meditative discourse is somewhat soporific.

Ironically, this show is a good example of the Jewish culture of endless argumentation about tiny Talmudic issues that is the ancient predecessor of the Jewish neuroses powering the comedic generator behind Seinfeld. This, however, isn't at all funny; it’s just long.

Men like these should be respected for their towering scholarship, but they need help producing engaging radio: a missed chance.

Related Website

http://www.whatisjudaism.com/learn/han2000.shtml