
This piece is a companion to an hour-long special episode of the program, BackStory with the American History Guys. The episode is called "Scales of Justice: A History of Supreme Court Nominations," and is currently available on ContentDepot and PRX.
In this piece, reporter Catherine Moore explores the earliest days of the Supreme Court, when Justices rode circuit, risking life and limb to bring their federal authority to America's hinterlands. In the process, they would help bind together a new nation. Helping her tell the story are historians Maeva Marcus and Peter Onuf.
This piece is offered at no cost. All we ask is that you use the language in the host intro/outro plugging the show, "BackStory."
More from BackStory with the American History Guys
Monumental Disagreements: Memorials in America
(00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
In this Memorial Day episode of BackStory, we take on national remembrance. By looking at some of our country’s most iconic monuments, we ask what—and whom—Americans choose ...
PROMO - Monumental Disagreements
(00:00:30)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
Promo for stations airing the episode "Monumental Disagreements."
PROMO - Home Bittersweet Home
(00:00:31)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
Promo for stations airing "Home Bittersweet Home"
PROMO - Born in the USA
(00:00:30)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
Promo for stations airing the BackStory episode "Born in the USA"
Home Bittersweet Home: A History of Homeownership
(00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
In 1931, Herbert Hoover called the idea of owning one’s own “a sentiment deep in the heart of our race and of American life.” In this episode of BackStory, the Guys take on ...
Born in the USA: A History of Birth
(00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
The American History Guys are back! In this premiere episode of BackStory's new weekly schedule, we explore the history of childbirth in America. Topics include everything ...
Civil War 150th: Questions Remain
(00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
In this third part of BackStory's "Civil War 150th" series, the History Guys host a special listener Q&A. Over the course of the hour, they answer a wide range of questions ...
Civil War 150th: Why They Fought
(00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
In the second episode of BackStory's "Civil War 150th" series, the History Guys look at what motivated Northerners and Southerners to take up arms against one another in ...
Civil War 150th: The Road to War
(00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys
To mark the sesquicentennial of the Civil War's beginnings, the History Guys take an in-depth look at the pivotal six months between Abraham Lincoln's election and the ...
Piece Description
This piece is a companion to an hour-long special episode of the program, BackStory with the American History Guys. The episode is called "Scales of Justice: A History of Supreme Court Nominations," and is currently available on ContentDepot and PRX.
In this piece, reporter Catherine Moore explores the earliest days of the Supreme Court, when Justices rode circuit, risking life and limb to bring their federal authority to America's hinterlands. In the process, they would help bind together a new nation. Helping her tell the story are historians Maeva Marcus and Peter Onuf.
This piece is offered at no cost. All we ask is that you use the language in the host intro/outro plugging the show, "BackStory."
Transcript
PIECE SCRIPT:
CATHERINE MOORE: Imagine you’re having a property dispute with one of your neighbors. He sues you. Next thing you know, a Supreme Court Justice shows up in town to hand down the verdict! This might sound crazy, but in the early republic, it happened.
The Judiciary Act of 1789 divided the country into three circuits, but it didn’t assign any judges to those seats. The idea was that Supreme Court Justices themselves would spend about half the year travelling all over the country holding court. It was called circuit riding. In the words of one Senator, this system “carr[ied] Law to [the people’s] Homes, Courts to their Doors.” Sounds like democracy, right? Well, the Justices hated it. Two years after they started riding circuit, they wrote to George Washington, pleading for an end to the practice:
READING: [:23] We […] find the burdens laid upon us so excessive that we c...
Read the full transcript
Intro and Outro
INTRO:The nomination of Elena Kagan to be the newest justice on the Supreme Court is now in the hands of the U.S Senate. As lawmakers exercise their “advise and consent” role, they will consider such things as Ms. Kagan’s legal scholarship, her judicial philosophy, and how well she gets along with her colleagues. But back at the beginning of our nation’s history, the position of Supreme Court justice called for a different set of qualifications, based on what justices would do when they weren’t at the Court. Because back then, they spent only about half their time – at most – in the capital city. Reporter Catherine Moore has the story of what happened the rest of the time.
OUTRO:That’s Catherine Moore. You can learn more about circuit riding – and other little-known chapters in Supreme Court history – on the latest episode of the program Catherine works for, “BackStory with the American History Guys.”
That episode can be heard right here on [STATION] at [TIME] on [DAY.]
OR
That episode can be found at backstoryradio dot org.




