Piece image

Should American Elections be Reformed?

Series: Global Ethics Corner
From: Carnegie Council
Length: 00:02:00

Is it time to reform the U.S. electoral structure? Should more views be represented? Do narrow interests have too much power? What do you think? Read the full description.

Globalethicscorner_logo1_small Created and managed by Carnegie Council Senior Program Director and Senior Fellow William Vocke, Global Ethics Corner is a weekly 90-second segment devoted to newsworthy ethical issues.

To hear the full audio, sign up for a free PRX account or log in.

Also in the Global Ethics Corner series

Piece image

Global Ethics Corner: Should Universities be Giving so Many Ph.D.'s? (00:02:01)
From: Carnegie Council

A Ph.D. used to be a ticket to a comfortable career in academia. But, in recent years, increasing numbers of Ph.D.'s have had trouble finding jobs or are earning less than ...
Piece image

Global Ethics Corner: Vigilante Justice: Have Libyans' Demands for Retribution Gone Too Far? (00:02:06)
From: Carnegie Council

Libya's civil war is over, but many victims of the Qaddafi regime are still violently meting out justice to their former oppressors. Will this just lead to a vicious cycle of ...
Piece image

Global Ethics Corner: When Are Drones Strikes Ethical? (00:01:53)
From: Carnegie Council

President Obama's top counterterrorism adviser recently defended drone strikes, saying they are legal, wise, and moral. But, citing international law, many critics question ...
Piece image

Global Ethics Corner: A Warrior Ethic: Can Military Ethics be Taught? (00:02:05)
From: Carnegie Council

After the recent highly publicized stories of American military members desecrating the remains of Taliban soldiers, many in the U.S. armed forces are learning about the ...
Piece image

Global Ethics Corner: Is the World Bank Outdated? (00:01:57)
From: Carnegie Council

With the election of another American to head the World Bank, some are questioning the institution's legitimacy and role in the world. Since once-impoverished nations are ...
Piece image

Global Ethics Corner: Do Super-Maximum Security Prisons Constitute Cruel and Unusual Punishment? (00:02:06)
From: Carnegie Council

A surprise ruling from the European Court of Human Rights could send five terror suspects to a super-maximum security prison in the United States. Is keeping inmates in ...
Piece image

Global Ethics Corner: Daisey and Foxconn: Is Exaggeration Acceptable When Raising Awareness? (00:02:02)
From: Carnegie Council

Mike Daisey has admitted to fabricating parts of his story on Foxconn for "This American Life." But, perhaps partly due to the attention his story received, the Chinese ...
Piece image

Global Ethics Corner: Health Care in America: Should all Americans have a Right to Affordable Care? (00:02:00)
From: Carnegie Council

With the Supreme Court set to make a decision, the Affordable Care Act is a major source of debate in the United States. Do all Americans have the right to affordable health ...
Piece image

Global Ethics Corner: Ethics in Banking: Is There Hope for Wall Street? (00:01:44)
From: Carnegie Council

The very public resignation of Goldman Sachs executive Greg Smith is the low point in a bad year for Wall Street. With the Occupy movement and a rumored recruiting crisis in ...
Piece image

Global Ethics Corner: "Kony 2012": The Power of Simplicity or the Perils of Oversimplification? (00:02:00)
From: Carnegie Council

Invisible Children's Kony 2012 campaign has reached critical mass and turned Joseph Kony into a household name. But does the organization's simplified message misinform the ...

Piece Description

Created and managed by Carnegie Council Senior Program Director and Senior Fellow William Vocke, Global Ethics Corner is a weekly 90-second segment devoted to newsworthy ethical issues.

Transcript

America is politically polarized. Part of the problem may be an outmoded electoral system, i.e. the combination of plurality voting, turnout, and primaries.

Most American elections are by plurality, "the winner takes all," and the winning candidate is "the first past the post."

The number of votes doesn't matter, as long as you get more than anyone else. For instance, 100 votes, ten candidates; one candidate gets 11 votes, the rest get equal shares; then the 11 wins.

The assumption was that candidates negotiate, compromise, and cooperate until a coalition of 51 votes is assembled. With this minimum winning coalition, policy moves toward the center, and compromise is the heart of the political process.

However, when voter turnout is low, only the most committed people vote. Primaries have especially low turnout; so winning a plural victory in a primary might require less than 10 perce...
Read the full transcript

Additional Credits

William Vocke- Producer, Program Director, Writer and Voice Talent
Deborah Carroll- Production Manager
Robert Smithline- Editor
Terence Hurley- Editor
Ina Pira- Media Coordinator

Related Website

www.carnegiecouncil.org