- Playing
- No Brother of Mine
- From
- 2 below zero
In an attempt to protect the public from sexual violence, the U.S. has enacted get-tough laws targeting released sex offenders. Many were inspired by high-profile cases in which children were raped and killed by strangers, a heinous albeit rare crime. Federal law now requires states to register all sex offenders online, including those committed of consensual teen sex and of public urination and indecent exposure. Dozens of states and municipalities have created buffer zones that prevent offenders from living near schools, playgrounds and parks. And about 20 states—including California, New York, Minnesota and Washington—indefinitely confine the worst offenders to mental hospitals.
Proponents contend that these laws make society safer. Opponents say they’re often ineffective and violate civil liberties.
Since 2006, award-winning producers Diane Richard and Todd Melby interviewed leading experts and victims’ advocates about the impact of these laws. They've also spent time getting to know four Minnesotans convicted of sex crimes, in prison and since their release. In many ways, these men represent the complexity of the issue. Their crimes span a spectrum of sexual violence. All are felons. Each completed a sex offender treatment program.
These men’s stories put a candid human face on the highly politicized issue of sex crimes, the damage they cause and some of their common roots. Together, the documentary provides a nuanced examination of issues surrounding online registration laws, residency restrictions, Romeo and Juliet laws and the growing use of civil commitment.
Produced with dual narrators, “No Brother of Mine” combines audio-rich storytelling that puts the listener in the scene with expert interviews to propel the narrative forward. The result is a probing look from many different perspectives at a nation grappling with how to handle the sensational yet banal reality of sexual violence and at the struggles released offenders face in a society that no longer wants them.
More from 2 below zero
Fight Night in Crude Country
(01:59)
From: 2 below zero
A visit to the Williston Basin Blowout, a night of mixed martial arts fights in Williston, North Dakota. For 30 bucks, attendees witnessed 10 fights. "I like it," one woman ...
They're Like Packs of Wolves
(04:37)
From: 2 below zero
When Nathina St. Pierre moved to Watford City, North Dakota, she received lots of attention from men. “It was flattering at first,” she said. But it never stopped. Everywhere ...
Catch of the Day
(04:22)
From: 2 below zero
Ben Audet is an oilfield hand who prefers bow fishing to video games.
They Call Us 'The Sardines'
(05:56)
From: 2 below zero
To make it in the Bakken boom, North Dakota newcomers need to work hard and make sacrifices. But what exactly are those sacrifices? Black Gold Boom reporter Todd Melby ...
Nowhere To Lay My Head
(03:09)
From: 2 below zero
They arrive in oil country by train, bus and automobile looking for work. Or if they're like Robby Reid, they shove everything they own into a backpack and hitchhike to North ...
Bryan Johnson: Oil Boom Traffic is Worse Than LA Rush Hour
(02:21)
From: 2 below zero
Bryan Johnson lives in Spearfish, South Dakota, and sells fire-retardant clothes to oil workers in Watford City, North Dakota. Before moving to Spearfish, he worked in Los ...
Richard Karpe: You Gotta Be Careful Out There
(02:33)
From: 2 below zero
While other boys were working on paper routes or not at all, Richard Karpe labored on drilling rigs. Today, he supervises a truck operation near Watford City, North Dakota.
Meet Bobcat John. He Sells Knives To Oil Workers.
(02:19)
From: 2 below zero
Bobcat John is a 57-year-old man from Idaho who came to the oil patch with his pickup truck and a trailer full of knives. His mission: Sell knives — all kinds of knives — to ...
Gotta Be An Eight
(01:50)
From: 2 below zero
Jayce Mitchell and Logan Bice moved to North Dakota to clean oil tankers. The pair were practicing their roping skills on a dummy steer, a plastic replica with horns at a ...
Tattoo Your Ride, Not Your Hide
(03:31)
From: 2 below zero
James Goeres sells pickup truck stickers from a mobile home. His motto: "Tattoo Your Ride, Not Your Hide."
Piece Description
In an attempt to protect the public from sexual violence, the U.S. has enacted get-tough laws targeting released sex offenders. Many were inspired by high-profile cases in which children were raped and killed by strangers, a heinous albeit rare crime. Federal law now requires states to register all sex offenders online, including those committed of consensual teen sex and of public urination and indecent exposure. Dozens of states and municipalities have created buffer zones that prevent offenders from living near schools, playgrounds and parks. And about 20 states—including California, New York, Minnesota and Washington—indefinitely confine the worst offenders to mental hospitals.
Proponents contend that these laws make society safer. Opponents say they’re often ineffective and violate civil liberties.
Since 2006, award-winning producers Diane Richard and Todd Melby interviewed leading experts and victims’ advocates about the impact of these laws. They've also spent time getting to know four Minnesotans convicted of sex crimes, in prison and since their release. In many ways, these men represent the complexity of the issue. Their crimes span a spectrum of sexual violence. All are felons. Each completed a sex offender treatment program.
These men’s stories put a candid human face on the highly politicized issue of sex crimes, the damage they cause and some of their common roots. Together, the documentary provides a nuanced examination of issues surrounding online registration laws, residency restrictions, Romeo and Juliet laws and the growing use of civil commitment.
Produced with dual narrators, “No Brother of Mine” combines audio-rich storytelling that puts the listener in the scene with expert interviews to propel the narrative forward. The result is a probing look from many different perspectives at a nation grappling with how to handle the sensational yet banal reality of sexual violence and at the struggles released offenders face in a society that no longer wants them.
5 Comments
|
Great reportingA nuanced look at a complicated issue - very informative and thought-provoking. |
|
So, what do we do?This is a well produced and thoughtful documentary. Because it's such an unpopular and tangled subject, what work do we need to do? Am I hearing the popular opinion that sex offenders can't be rehabilitated is a myth? Calm, thoughtful, no apologies for perpetrators. People need to hear this. That's about my highest recommendation. |
Broadcast History
Not aired nationally.
Transcript
59-minute version Version
BILLBOARD
Sex offenders are among the most feared and demonized people in America. Especially when one moves in close to home.
I have a 10-year-old daughter. I let her roam. Now, you know, I’m scared to death now. I don’t want her out of my house.
In an effort to prevent future sex crimes, many states restrict where offenders can live after their release from prison.
The problem is not so much where they live as where they are, what they’re doing. In many ways, it creates a false sense of security.
Other states keep some offenders locked up even after they’ve completed their criminal sentences. It’s a controversial practice that critics argue is unconstitutional.
I’m Todd Melby.
In the next hour, reporter Diane Richard and I will explore whether these get tough laws are the best way to prevent future sex crimes. We talk to offenders, experts and worried citizens.
Our documentary...
Read the full transcript
54-minute version Version
BILLBOARD
Sex offenders are among the most feared and demonized people in America. Especially when one moves in close to home.
I have a 10-year-old daughter. I let her roam. Now, you know, I’m scared to death now. I don’t want her out of my house.
In an effort to prevent future sex crimes, many states restrict where offenders can live after their release from prison.
The problem is not so much where they live as where they are, what they’re doing. In many ways, it creates a false sense of security.
Other states keep some offenders locked up even after they’ve completed their criminal sentences. It’s a controversial practice that critics argue is unconstitutional.
I’m Todd Melby.
In the next hour, reporter Diane Richard and I will explore whether these get tough laws are the best way to prevent future sex crimes. We talk to offenders, experts and worried citizens.
Our documentary...
Read the full transcript
Timing and Cues
Billboard (0:59)
Outcue: "Our documentary is called 'No Brother of Mine.'"
Newshole (5:00)
Segment A (14:03)
Outcue: "Just because it says on a piece of paper 'statutory rape,' that doesn't mean that I raped this person."
Music Bridge (1:00)
Segment B (19:44)
Outcue: "I was one of those type people who, if you weren't for me, you were against me. And if you were against me, God have mercy on you, because I was going to get you."
Music Bridge (1:00)
Segment C (17:13)
Outcue: "Thanks for listening." Followed by 0:14 of music.
Musical Works
| Title | Artist | Album | Label | Year | Length |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Breathe Me | Sia | Six Feet Under, Vol. 2: Everything Ends. | 00:00 | ||
| Transatlanticism | Death Cab for Cutie | Six Feet Under, Vol. 2: Everything Ends. | 00:00 | ||
| Flugufrelsarinn (Kronos Version) | Kronos Quartet | Plays Sigur Ros - Single. | 00:00 | ||
| Etude V | Philip Glass | Etudes for Piano Vol. I, No. 1-10. | 00:00 |
Additional Credits
The editor was Robbie Harris. Funding from the Fund for Investigative Journalism and individual contributors to 2 below zero.






Jon Kalish
Posted on April 14, 2010 at 09:22 AM | Permalink
Years Spent on this Doc Pay off
Where else but in public radio do you get to hear a documentary produced by two people who literally spent years gathering tape and following subjects around? My hat's off to Melby and Richard for grappling with such a hot-button issue. I am someone who had a horrific crime committed against my child and I did not expect to be receptive to this doc. But the producers managed to tell the stories of these sex offenders without coddling them. I also applaud the producers for examining the civil liberties implications of the essentially permanent incarceration advocated by hardliners in the sex offender debate. This is just a solid, well-constructed doc and I am the wiser for having listened to it.
Jon Kalish, NYC-based podcast and radio producer