Piece image

Matthew and the Judge: Juvenile Court Diary

From: Radio Diaries
Series: Prison Diaries
Length: 33:41

Radio Diaries gave both Judge Jeremiah, a Rhode Island juvenile court judge, and Matthew, a 16-year-old repeat offender, tape recorders in 2001. Judge Jeremiah released Matthew early, for good behavior. Two weeks later, Matthew was arrested again for selling drugs. Through their diaries, Matthew and the judge tell the same story from two different sides of the bench. Read the full description.

Jeremiah_small In 2001, Radio Diaries gave both Judge Jeremiah, a Rhode Island juvenile court judge, and Matthew, a 16-year-old repeat offender, tape recorders. Judge Jeremiah released Matthew early, for good behavior. Two weeks later, Matthew was arrested again for selling drugs. Through their diaries, Matthew and the judge tell the same story from two different sides of the bench. 

A year and a half after this story aired, our friend and diarist 18-year-old Matthew Omisore was killed. 

To hear the full audio, sign up for a free PRX account or log in.

More from Radio Diaries

Piece image

Going Home: Cristel's Diary (20:05)
From: Radio Diaries

At the age of 15, Cristel viciously attacked a rival classmate with a razor blade.
Piece image

Serving 9 to 5: Correctional Officers' Diary (19:19)
From: Radio Diaries

Sergeant Furman Camel is retiring after 27 years.
Piece image

Doing Time: John's Diary (18:28)
From: Radio Diaries

John Mills, a 21-year-old inmate, is serving seven to nine years.
Caption: Melissa in 2013., Credit: David Gilkey/NPR

Teenage Diaries Revisited Podcast: Melissa (40:01)
From: Radio Diaries

Listen to Melissa's teenage and grown-up diaries in this podcast episode.
Caption: Melissa in 2013., Credit: David Gilkey/NPR

Teenage Diaries Revisited: Melissa (19:36)
From: Radio Diaries

As an 18-year-old raised in the foster care system, Melissa took NPR listeners along when she gave birth to her son Isaaiah. Over the past 16 years Melissa and her son have ...
Caption: Josh Cutler in 2013, Credit: David Gilkey/NPR

Teenage Diaries Revisited Podcast: Josh (40:12)
From: Radio Diaries

In high school, Josh Cutler documented his life with Tourette’s Syndrome, a neurological disorder that causes uncontrollable tics and involuntary verbal outbursts. 16 years ...
Caption: Amanda in 2013, Credit: David Gilkey/NPR

Teenage Diaries Revisited: Amanda (17:32)
From: Radio Diaries

At the age of 17, Amanda knew she was gay. But her parents kept insisting she’d grow out of it. Today, a lot has changed in the country, and within her own family. 16 years ...
Piece image

Miss Subways (14:15)
From: Radio Diaries

Beauty pageants promote the fantasy of the ideal woman. But for 35 years, the Miss Subways contest in New York City celebrated the everyday working girl.
Piece image

Segregation Now, Segregation Forever: The Infamous Words of George Wallace (16:46)
From: Radio Diaries

On the 50th anniversary of Wallace’s inaugural speech as the Governor of Alabama, Radio Diaries tells the story behind those infamous words, and the man who delivered them.
Piece image

The Two Lives of Asa Carter (12:42)
From: Radio Diaries

Asa Carter and Forrest Carter couldn’t have been more different. But they shared a secret.

Piece Description

In 2001, Radio Diaries gave both Judge Jeremiah, a Rhode Island juvenile court judge, and Matthew, a 16-year-old repeat offender, tape recorders. Judge Jeremiah released Matthew early, for good behavior. Two weeks later, Matthew was arrested again for selling drugs. Through their diaries, Matthew and the judge tell the same story from two different sides of the bench. 

A year and a half after this story aired, our friend and diarist 18-year-old Matthew Omisore was killed. 

1 Comment Atom Feed

User image

Review of Matthew and the Judge: Juvenile Court Diary

It's a privilege to be so deep inside someone's head and in this case,
inside the heads of two people on opposite sides of "the bar." I like the
way the material is organized. We meet Matthew first and get a sense of him
before we actually know everything he's done wrong, and we get to know the
judge a little before we hear them together. It's very moving to hear the judge's journey from compassionate hope to resigned disappointment, and to hear Matthew's parallel journey from hope to despair. I wanted to put my head down and cry as this piece drew to its close. Knowing Matthew is dead makes the close of this piece that much more heartbreaking. It's beautiful, respectful and could air any time, but certainly when there is big news on youth crime. sl

Broadcast History

This piece originally aired on NPR through All Things Considered.

Transcript

Matthew and the Judge: Juvenile Court Diary
Prison Diaries
Produced by: Joe Richman All Things Considered (NPR)
1/16/2001

LINDA WERTHEIMER, HOST: For the past 14 years Judge Jeremiah S. Jeremiah has been chief judge of the Rhode Island Family Court. Part of his job is to decide whether a juvenile offender is sent back home to his family, placed in foster care, sent to a halfway house, or like sixteen-year-old Matthew, incarcerated at the Rhode Island Training School. Matthew and Judge Jeremiah were both given tape recorders, they kept audio diaries over the course of the year, telling the same story but from opposite sides of the bench.

MATTHEW: My name?s Matthew. I?m locked up. I got incarcerated for the first time at the age of 13. Did a couple months, got out. Stayed out for a little while, got arrested again. Did some more time. Got out. Came back. I?m still here.

[Hear walkie-...
Read the full transcript

Related Website

http://www.radiodiaries.org/