Caption: Hanging a Stocking, 1901
Hanging a Stocking, 1901 

Naughty & Nice: A History of The Holiday Season

From: BackStory with the American History Guys
Length: 00:54:00

The History Guys trace the evolution of Christmas from a rowdy festival of misbehavior to the domestic, child-centered holiday that it is today. Read the full description.
${title}
To hear the full audio, sign up for a free PRX account or log in.

More from BackStory with the American History Guys

Piece image

In the Beginning: Evolution and Creation in American History (00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

More than 85 years after the Scopes “Monkey Trial,” debates over the proper place of Darwin in American schools are alive and well. In this episode of BackStory, the History ...
Caption: Uncle Sam's choice of Liberty Bonds or shackles inscribed 'Prussia.' NY Evening Post, 1917, Credit: Library of Congress

Borrowed Times: A History of the National Debt (00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

On this episode, the History Guys explore why debt has continued to be so controversial in a nation that was founded on borrowing. Have there been times in American history ...
Caption: City Point, VA (1865), Credit: Library of Congress

Civil War 150th: Questions Remain (00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

In this third part of BackStory's "Civil War 150th" series, the History Guys host a special listener Q&A. Over the course of the hour, they answer a wide range of questions ...
Caption: Two Soldiers from the 23rd New York Infantry, ca. 1861-1865, Credit: Library of Congress

Civil War 150th: Why They Fought (00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

In the second episode of BackStory's "Civil War 150th" series, the History Guys look at what motivated Northerners and Southerners to take up arms against one another in ...
Caption: "The Hercules of Union Slaying the Great Dragon of Secession," 1861 , Credit: Library of Congress

Civil War 150th: The Road to War (00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

To mark the sesquicentennial of the Civil War's beginnings, the History Guys take an in-depth look at the pivotal six months between Abraham Lincoln's election and the ...
Piece image

Beyond Numbers: A History of the U.S. Census (00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

The History Guys dig into the little-considered story of the U.S. Census – the invisible backbone of our democracy. As it turns out, the idea of doling out power based on the ...
Caption: "Houdini and the ghost of Abraham Lincoln," ca. 1920, Credit: Library of Congress

American Spirit: A History of the Supernatural (00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

On this Halloween special, BackStory explores Americans' relationship with ghosts, spirits, and witches throughout our nation's history. Why were colonists so fearful of New ...
Caption: A writ of execution issued by Chief Justice John Jay, while riding circuit in NH., Credit: US District Court - NH

Justice on Horseback (00:04:34)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

Before "The People's Court," there was the circuit riding system. Supreme Court Justices traveled all over the country delivering--as one Senator put it--"law to the people's ...
Caption: Taft Court, Taken by Harris & Ewing (between 1921-30), Credit: Library of Congress

Scales of Justice: A History of Supreme Court Nominations (00:54:00)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

Another summer, another Supreme Court vacancy! Join the History Guys as they explore the highlights – and lowlights – of Supreme Court nominations past.
Piece image

Grave Matters: A History of Death and Mourning (00:53:53)
From: BackStory with the American History Guys

A look at the ways Americans have remembered their dead, from the Revolutionary War up through the present.

Piece Description

Christmas may be the Big Kahuna of American holy days… but it wasn’t always so. For many centuries, it was a time of drunken rowdiness, when the poor would aggressively demand food and money from the rich. Little surprise, then, that the Puritans banned Christmas altogether. In fact, it wasn’t until the 1820s that the holiday was re-invented as the peaceful, family-oriented, and yes, consumeristic ritual we celebrate today.

BackStory’s year-end special takes on the fascinating history of the “holiday season” in America. Beginning with contemporary debates over the proper role of religion in the public square, the History Guys move backwards in time, searching for the roots of the holidays we celebrate today. Has Christmas grown more or less religious? When did gifts enter the picture? Was Hanukkah always as important to American Jews as it is today? What does the history of holidays have to do with the history of the American economy? These are just a few of the questions on the table as the History Guys explore the history of the winter holidays.

Highlights Include:

  • Historian Stephen Nissenbaum (The Battle for Christmas) describes how in the 1820s, Christmas changed from a raucous street fest into a domesticated, gift-centered holiday.
  • Fox News Radio host John Gibson explains why he thinks there's a "war on Christmas."
  • Rabbi Laura Baum (ourjewishcommunity.org) explains how the Hanukkah story came into being, and why telling kids the truth about its origins doesn’t diminish the holiday.
  • Tyrone Jones talks about what it’s like to be a Santa Claus who doesn’t look like the Norman Rockwell prototype.
  • BackStory listeners phone in with their questions about the history of the holiday season.

Additional Files