Piece image

To Hug or Not to Hug?

From: Steven Tagle
Length: 05:30

This short audio essay questions the male aversion to heartfelt hugs. Read the full description.

3398550602050alb_small This short audio essay questions the male aversion to heartfelt hugs. It combines personal anecdotes with a description of a man-hug and gives examples of the man-hug in the media.

To hear the full audio, sign up for a free PRX account or log in.

More from Steven Tagle

Caption: PRX default Piece image

And Van Der Waals Said (01:22)
From: Steven Tagle

A poem that relates chemistry to relationships.
Piece image

Me and My Monkey (18:25)
From: Steven Tagle

This long audio essay explores primate research and the conflict that exists between treating monkeys humanely and treating them like humans.

Piece Description

This short audio essay questions the male aversion to heartfelt hugs. It combines personal anecdotes with a description of a man-hug and gives examples of the man-hug in the media.

7 Comments Atom Feed

User image

Review of To Hug or Not to Hug?

This is of a guy who is explaining the man hug and why it isn't right between friend and that guys just need to buck up and hug correctly, not in those exact words though. He explains that real friends don't hug like that, that real men hug correctly. The story was, though weird, pretty well written and I would listen to another like it.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of To Hug or Not to Hug?

Wow! I had never thought about hugs so deeply until know, there's not a school day that goes by were I don't receive hug. Hugs mean a lot to me. They can cheer you up, let you know that some one cares, or even show that someone is trying to show you some affection.
I would consider my friends and I manly men, we eat meat that is cooked over an open flame, like man was meant to eat. Yet we still share big hugs and deep intimate conversations together all the time.
Steven did a great job at writing this piece. I really enjoyed the parts where it was written somewhat mockingly to keep it funny, but it still had a joking/serious point to it as well. Also to point out how society and mainstream media view and mock a male-to-male "heartfelt hug" was absolutely great.
I would love to hear this piece get played on the air around here, but the community is a slightly anti-gay community so I don’t know that it would sit so well with a lot of people.
I think this piece is great the way that it is. It got me to think about the topic and made me smile, so nothin' but kudos from this male-to-male "heartfelt hug" fan.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of To Hug or Not to Hug?

This is an interesting essay, although I do think that Steven Tagle over-interprets male body-language. Yes, men often growl when they hug, but so do ladies when they go chest-to-chest. (Though, of course, it could be purring.)

By the way, the real male huggers in this world are not necessarily New Age or gay at all: they are merely Portuguese. Watch carefully: as Portuguese men (businessmen, politicians, everyone) extend their right hands for a shake, with their left hands they grasp each other tight around the back, and hug, and hug, and hug--turning even the most formal first encounter into a full-body grapple.

Back to radio: I think this essay would make a wonderful feature sound-piece, with the Steven's narration interspersed with real, live, you-are-there hug recordings. I can hear them now:

"Oh, John!...
"Oh, James!...

(Sound of male hug: "Grrrrr!" +pat-pat-pat)

Followed, of course, by:

"Oh, Latanya!......
"Oh, Trixie!!!..."

(Sound of female hug: "MMMMMmmm!...Purrrr!" + pat-pat-pat)

Unfortunately, I suspect that actual hug field recordings will turn out to be far less dramatic than the above, and sound more like:

(Traffic ambience. Then

"OK, so, like, I'll see you..."
"OK, like, whatever..."

Traffic fades...)

Thus, the radio hug will have to be cued in some way, perhaps with music provided by a convenient orchestra or, these days, cell-phone signal.

There are infinite possibilities. And I hereby give Steven Tagle an encouraging male...I mean, email...hug. (Grrr...pat-pat-pat...Music soars.)

See all 7 comments >>

Transcript

Steven Tagle

To Hug or Not to Hug?

Steven Tagle questions the male aversion to sharing heartfelt hugs.

It’s about nine o’clock at night, the day before school starts, and my best friend and I are standing on his porch. Hugging. We’ve been at it for about two minutes now, but I’m not counting. The quiet takes us over and it’s okay just to stand there, bathed in porch light, holding each other once the hug’s worn off. I don’t know how to describe it other than warm. Jason hugs me, and I hug back, all the while wondering if he’s cold in that small black t-shirt. We stand and hold, heads nestled on our shoulders, prolonging our goodbye with soft sighs. Leaving home each fall is tough, and these hugs are the reason why. These hugs make me miss him before we even start to let go.

Jason and I don’t hug because we’re gay. We don’t hug because we’re “girlie men.” We hug be...
Read the full transcript

Related Website

http://www.stanford.edu/~stagle